How will these US consumer giants cope with a slowing economy?
How will these US consumer giants cope with a slowing economy?
About this video
Tim Davies from Carrara Capital joins us to discuss how the existent financial climate in America unveils a noticeable disparity in debt ratios and consumer spending power. Tim notes that even though crucial economic indicators such as PMI services and manufacturing remain roughly 20% below June 2021 levels, these data seem to be overlooked by stock markets. He highlights alarming issues such as the surging student loan debt, currently approaching $2 trillion, and the rapid increase in auto loans, now twice the levels of 2008, indicating the rising financial strain of the American consumer.
Moreover, Tim analyzes the potential risks looming over three major companies - McDonald's, Starbucks, and Walmart - due to the deteriorating consumer debt situation. In the case of McDonald's, he identifies franchising expenses and the subsequent frail balance sheet caused by vigorous share buybacks as problematic. Starbucks, he claims, despite its American popularity, has encountered difficulties during international growth, leading to lower returns outside America. Walmart, on the other hand, grapples with tough competition from online contender Amazon and inflation. Tim winds up by indicating a grim prospect for these corporations, attributable to their inflated PM multiples, frail balance sheets, and overreliance on the American market.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
All three main US economic condition indices. PMI Services Manufacturing Composite remaining over 20% below their June 2021 peak. They've only risen slightly from the trough level in December 2022. US stock market indices, meanwhile,
0:15
seemingly disregarding this data. Tim Davies from Carrara Capital joins me now at the desk to discuss what is behind this disconnect. What are you seeing, Tim? Good morning. Yeah, so we've been taking a really close look at the US consumer. I think it's sort of a continuation on a on our work that we've done at just the scale of US debt that needs to be refunded over the last 18 months, potentially crowding out credit markets for privates who need to come to market and roll over their own debt. So it's been a really interesting exercise, actually starting to take look at a better picture of how that US consumer is beginning to suffer and how is the US consumer beginning to suffer. I was just talking there about the potential government shut down. People don't get paid. They're not going to be spending, are they? Yeah, exactly. Exactly. I think it's a lot broader. So if we look at some sort of key metrics around where the US consumer is accumulating debt, if we first look at student loan debt, it's up about three fold since the GFC. So
1:13
a lot of people have gone back to university or to higher education and taking on quite significant student loan debt that's now approaching $2 trillion. Another side is also their auto loans. So if we think back to the 2008 GFC peak, auto loans capped out at about $800 billion or so, they've really skyrocketed over the last five years or so. So they're now double that sort of level close to 1.1. $6 trillion. And how do you think we can potentially see that being reversed? I note that you're looking at those consumer debt levels, but as well, we've been looking at student loans increasing quite substantially, too.
1:54
Well, that's a hard one, I think. I mean,
1:57
a question whether the government running 8% deficits at the moment can afford to step in and start paying off some of those loans. I know President Biden had discussed in the past of helping to alleviate some of the pressure on student loans, but it's kind of come and go on the scale of what they were talking at. What we're starting to see is heavy reliance on credit cards. So US credit card debt just topped $1 trillion for the first time and savings rates are collapsing as well. So we're starting to see the impact of inflation coming through on people's hip pockets. Traditionally, the US saved around about 8 to 10% of their wages each year. Now it's dropped to as low as 2% at the moment. So the US consumer is really under pressure on multiple fronts and you're looking at some of the stocks that could be affected by this. So why do you see McDonald's at a risk? Because isn't that where people go when they're worried about money? They go to those cheap fast food places? Yeah, look, it's it's
2:57
an incredibly interesting business as a case study, I'm sure universities in the future will rip McDonald's apart. It's not what we think it is like. We think of McDonald's as this brand that owns a lot of land and it owns the stores that we shop at. In fact, McDonald's itself only owns 5% of its stores, so it's 95% of them have been franchised.
3:20
About 5 or 6 years ago, McDonald's, along with several other large US companies, decided to aggressively buy back shares and take on tens of billions of dollars of debt. When debt was trading at around that 0 to 2% range. So they've got a very, very weak balance sheet. The other part I think that's really interesting in McDonald's is instead of growing stores that were very profitable or stores that would contribute significantly to the bottom line. McDonald's embarked on a campaign of of licensing or franchising stores across emerging markets. And this has really been 100% of their store growth over the last five years. Now, what's interesting is that franchise keeps $0.95 in the dollar of what they generate each day. And if you run the numbers, I mean, McDonald's is literally taking $250 per store and $40 per day of operating income per store across almost 20,000 of these licensed stores. So they
4:20
sell a story of growth of this huge footprint. But the challenge is that almost half of those stores are only contributing 3% of their operating income. So in a way, you'd say that management of gutted out McDonald's earnings potential because of pushing out this licensing business and in favor of buying back, you know, roughly $50 Billion worth of shares over the last decade or so and really putting all of the cost of that buyback onto its balance sheet. You are looking at Starbucks as well. Now, this is so interesting because, you know, coffee snobs here in Australia, not not. Not our favorite. Americans love it. They absolutely love it. Doesn't matter what kind of coffee shop is, they'll look for Starbucks. What are you seeing in terms of foreigners, though, preferring their local brands? Yeah. So again, it's really interesting. So it's it's a similar story to McDonald's in that Starbucks have aggressively added $20 billion a share. Buybacks late in the late 20 tens
5:20
accumulated huge debt. When you look at the business itself, it's incredibly dependent upon the US consumer. So almost 80% of its revenue comes from roughly 50% of its stores that are located in the US. As you touched on, if we look at their international operations, we see that only 30% of revenue per store equivalent to the US. So there's a lot of evidence of what you've touched on is that foreigners don't particularly like to go to Starbucks to buy their coffee, and yet management is aggressively rolled out huge footprints that generate relatively low returns around 20% margins relative to what they would from their own US operations. Looking at Walmart, I mean, it was interesting the movement in Amazon overnight because the FTC basically saying, look, you've got a monopoly here and that is really impacting the likes of Walmart to plus these inflationary pressures. Yeah.
6:20
So Walmart you know Walmart's quite different Again it's it's this Walmart's put a lot of money and a lot of time into growing globally so roughly 37% of their store footprint is offshore. It's performing really badly relative to the US. So again, we've got a company that's highly dependent upon that overstretched US consumer is in facing is facing significant inflation pressure. Obviously traditionally it's purchased a lot of its goods from China. So it's facing a lot of pressure there as well as potentially finding new homes. So Walmart's another one. All three of these stocks trade at very high multiples. So p multiples in the high 20s. And we think relative to their weak balance sheets, their exposure to a weakening US consumer and their valuations are just wrong. So we think all three of these US consumer stocks, if we see further pressure of the US consumer, all three of them stand out as potentially facing quite steep, sharp declines over the next 12
7:20
months.