How to manage investments in a heightened global risk environment
How to manage investments in a heightened global risk environment
About this video
Tim Davies from Carrara Capital shares his perspective on the potential impact of geopolitical risks and changing market dynamics on investment strategies. Amidst rising tensions in the Middle East, oil price changes are at the forefront. Tim suggests that the expected interest rate cuts being delayed could disrupt the favourable market conditions that investors have enjoyed for the past 12 months. He further discussed concerns surrounding a potential rise in inflation, which could pose significant risks to NASDAQ valuations, especially tech stocks that have witnessed considerable growth.
In response to these market uncertainties, Tim suggests that investors examine their asset valuations, giving particular attention to Asian markets. Inflationary pressures and potential bottlenecks in oil supply due to escalating Middle East tensions could further complicate the economic climate. Looking at the gold market, Tim views gold equities as attractive, despite the recent spike, and suggests incremental investments as a prudent approach.
Discussing the potential of alternative energy and electric vehicle markets, Tim recognises Tesla's(TSLA) pivot towards battery production but identifies a period of stagnation in Tesla's growth, while other companies like BYD show signs of accelerating growth with plans for global factories. Lastly, Tim remains optimistic about the growth of Chinese equities citing the strength of China's manufacturing sector and favourable valuations as keys to their potential success, despite ongoing issues in the country's property sector.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Let's get into how investors are positioning amidst the rising tensions in the Middle East and how you go about managing your portfolio in this environment. Tim Davies from Carrara Capital joins me now. Tim, I mean, the humanitarian side aside, I should say, I mean, it's horrific what we're seeing day to day, but it's very much played into the geopolitical risk scenario and the oil price scenario. How are you sort of positioning or what do you suggest? Yeah, look, it's definitely really interesting. I think, um, you know, we've kind of been in this Goldilocks for the last 12 months. I think the Nasdaq is still up about 31% in the last 12 months. And a lot of it's been on expectations that inflation was tame, energy prices had stabilised. And we were going to start to see one, maybe 1.25% interest rate cuts. Yeah. Uh, and now we're hearing, you know, overnight from, um, the Federal Reserve Chairman Powell, that's been delayed. And it's interesting. Morningstar's, you know, some data looked at this morning saying that we may actually not see any rate cuts at all this year.
0:59
So, um, that may damage that Goldilocks kind of game that's been playing in markets for a while. Absolutely. I had a guest yesterday that actually said he thinks it's more likely that there will be a hike this year than, than any cuts. Um, we're also adjusting to all these inflationary pressures. And we saw that in that hotter than expected CPI, CPI in the US. Do we see then a renewed spike in inflation? And if so, what does that mean for the oil market for markets in general. So yeah I think you know the Nasdaq is on 33 times forward earnings. Um, you know that was really built off this expectation, as I said, that rates were going to come off. Um, you know the US two year touched 5% last night. Two year note. So, um, you know that's the longer we sort of have this heightened, um, interest rate environment, this delay, you know, I think it starts to pose a real risk to the valuations of Nasdaq, particularly some of those tech stocks that were just kept
1:59
going up and up and up. Um, we could see you know, the risk is a significant fall in some of these markets, back to back to levels that probably more realistically, um, signify that sort of 5% interest rate that may stay for a period of time. So what what does that mean? It means, I mean, we could see a 20% fall on the Nasdaq and S&P 500 quite easily. So you back away from the Magnificent Seven. Um, look, it's an interesting one. I mean, I think if you look at the businesses themselves, right, they're doing incredibly well and they will continue to do well. The demand for whether it's Nvidia chips or SK Hynix, Samsung memory chips, the demand isn't going to change. It's just a function of the multiples. So, um, you know, we look at these things and say to ourselves, look, you know, we've been over the last couple of months, we've been talking about Asia and saying the valuations there are a fraction of what they are in the US. So I think it's a function of of just investors having a really good look at the valuations and saying to themselves,
2:59
look, um, yes, the growth is there, but is the price over inflated relative to that, to that growth story? Let's have a look at what we're seeing as well in I mean, we touched on oil but specifically gold which is continuing to rise. And now these very bullish calls from the likes of Citi Goldman Sachs, many saying $3,000 as well. Um, do you add exposure here when you've seen a 10% jump in the past month? I think, you know, you've got to kind of stand back from the gold market, right? So if we go back to 2011, the price almost hit 2000. And so if we look over a very long period of time, we've seen massive expansion in central bank balance sheets. Um, we've got the US sitting at 130% debt to GDP. We've got, you know, Bank of America said their interest bills probably going to be close to $1.8 trillion this year. They're also running a fiscal deficit in the country. So, you know, the US is racking up bills at more than 10% of its GDP. So, you know, I think people
3:59
are starting to question the balance sheet issues around, um, the US and also, you know, US Treasury bonds, central banks haven't bought on a net basis US debt since 2014. So we're seeing central banks piling into gold. Um, we're seeing a lot of the physical gold being taken off the market. And if you look at the other side of the coin, investment portfolios, people have very, very little exposure to it, whether it's through physical bullion or whether it's through equities, equities, gold equities are still a fraction of where they are relative to where the gold price is today. So again, I think to answer your question, um, you know, we think gold goes a lot higher. Um, and we think gold equities are very, very attractive. Um, yes. They have had a, you know, a decent spike. So I think like most things, stepping in carefully and slowly and building a position over time is always better than sort of having that one bet and saying, I've got to own
4:58
gold today.
5:00
Um, we touched on on the potential delay in in rate cuts in the US. What does it mean though. And I know we always sort of talk about follow the leader, but we've talked about whether or not the ECB cuts first, but also what happens here in Australia because a lot of data points are suggesting some kinks in the economy. And I was kind of quite interested by the car arrears data yesterday. I mean, people can't even pay off their car loans. Then how are they going with their mortgages? How are they going with rising gas prices? You know, how does all that play into the RBA's thinking, too? Yeah, I think all central banks are getting squeezed in your corner. It's a really difficult situation whereby rates have been a lot higher than they have been. And the impact on people's, you know, people's savings are probably dwindling. As you said, they're struggling to pay bills. More and more people are suffering financial stress. Um, the challenge though is, is oil, right. As it's energy prices, whether it's I mean, things like the Straits of Hormuz in, in the Middle East, 30% of oil flows
6:00
through a three kilometre channel that sits off the coast of Iran. So, um, there's some serious choke points in the world that that any action by Iran in that area could cause a significant huge spike in oil. I mean, 120, $150. People talk about if there was any serious military action in that in that area. All of this is inflationary pressure, whether it's impacting trade routes, whether it's impacting energy supply, whether it's impacting expectations, it'll eventually flow flowing to food, it will flow into all sorts of things. So the risk is we start to see inflation pick up. And in that environment central banks are really going to struggle to cut rates. Um, for the consumer it means prices go up and more financial stress. Um, so it's a really difficult situation. I think again, if we think about where valuations are and a lot of global equity markets, that Goldilocks sort of viewpoint starts to
7:00
crumble when you start to think about central banks losing the ability to perhaps lower interest rates to stimulate their economy at a time when the risk of inflationary upside is building. Do you get ahead of the curve, then, particularly with the stress in the energy market, and go to those electric vehicle companies that I know you like?
7:20
Um, look, I, you know, we love the idea, right? Like BYD's the last results they just announced for new global factories. So, you know, they'll do about 4.5 million cars next year. Those factories fully operating probably get them to eight. Um, as we've always said, we really like Tesla. But the challenge for Tesla in 2024 and going into 2025 is they've sort of pivoted to focus on the battery and getting the cost of production lower for their next range rather than build capacity. So, you know, Tesla is at a flat spot. Um, and it's expensive. It trades at more than double the price of Bhiwadi. And I think Birdie's really laid out a strong plan for accelerating the growth, accelerating its EV exports. And it's positioning these factories in emerging markets where a lot of that demand for a 20, $25,000 car is going to come from. So we think Bellwethers pulled ahead significantly. If Tesla is a business model. Um, Tesla's got a lot of work to do to catch up. I do believe they
8:20
will get there over time, but I think, um, you know, potentially the price comes off further, you know, potentially down to about $120 or so, I think is in in that weaker global equity market, particularly the US equity markets, we could see Tesla, you know, see more downside before um, you know it gets attractive again. But long term I still think it's a fantastic company. And just a quick word on China I mean that growth picture yesterday always so interesting when they they come out better than expected. Um is it sustainable. Yeah I think it is. Yeah definitely I think yeah I think one of the challenges is the year on year comparisons. So some of the data retail sales, industrial production was weaker but GDP was strong for us. You know, we've been saying over the last year that it's it's the incremental small additions that they're making. It's the incremental, um, support for the property market that's having less of a dent in GDP. So, yes, there are still problems in the property sector, but I think they're getting less and less. Um,
9:20
what we are hearing in general, Yellen was there last week. I mean, I was shocked when she came out and made a comment that said the Chinese economic system appears to be functioning better than the Western one. I mean, I was completely shocked when she said that and down to communism. It was really interesting actually, to hear that from her. But, um, you know, I think that it means that, um, you know, the world is, is facing a challenge from China in that they've had their head down for the last ten years and built this monumental manufacturing, uh, and they make things a lot cheaper than everyone else in the world. And, um, we're going to see at a time when balance sheets are stressed and interest rates are high, um, governments need. To put a lot of capital into investing in their manufacturing, whether it's in Europe or the US. And, um, it's going to take them a long time to catch up. I mean, the Siemens CEO came out yesterday. The CFO came out and said, look, it'll take us 20 years to decouple from China. Um, so it's a, you know, they've got a lead, I think, for a while and longer term for for Chinese
10:19
equities. It's really positive. I think given the valuation and the, um, and the strength of their, of their manufacturing sector.