How listed active managers positioned to compete against ETFs
How listed active managers positioned to compete against ETFs
About this video
Discussing prevailing investment trends, Shaun Ler from Morningstar discussed his view on the performance of listed asset managers in the face of recent macro developments. Shaun perceives that while the broader macro trends are currently more favourable than they were about six months to one year ago, not all asset managers stand to benefit equally. Encouraging for many asset managers as Shaun expects, is the prediction of falling global interest rates which can increase investors' appetite for stocks, thereby enhancing fund flows and asset prices.
Shaun further delves into the situation for asset managers, stating that there may be a trend of exaggerated optimism. He draws attention to the claim amongst managers of 'record money on the sidelines'. However, most of the institutional rebalancing activity has already occurred, leaving the proportions of cash, bonds, and stocks in portfolios more balanced. Regardless, Shaun maintains that the outlook remains precarious and closely tied to interest rate expectations.
Towards the conclusion, Shaun shares his insight on the influence of global markets on Australian listed-active managers. He suggests Australia’s interest rates aren't the only factor impacting the flow trajectory. Regardless of Australia being 'behind the curve', he concludes, it will invariably align with global counterparts. Moreover, he mentions Pinnacle (ASX:PNI) who is successfully navigating these market challenges, but warns investors to avoid chasing the momentum and buying stocks at high prices.
Full unedited transcript:
0:00
Hell, a list of active managers positioned to compete against the likes of ETFs and super funds will shortly is joining us from Morningstar to discuss that outlook. Shawn, good to catch up with you again. Let's take a look at what we're seeing in that area of listed active managers. How do you assess their performance at the moment?
0:21
Well, so thanks for having me. Um, like I think that, you know, for most of the asset managers, the short answer is that the broader macro trends are now more favorable than they were about six months to one year ago. But not all will similarly benefit from this. The overall flow outlook is generally positive for most of these guys. You know, the main swing factor over here, um, is interest rates. I think consensus is implying that global interest rates will fall. We see that the ECB has cut rates once in June and some are expecting um, the US fed to cut rates in 2024. So this improve um interest rate rhetoric has somewhat improved investor appetite for stocks. Uh which means for many, many asset managers um improved fund flows, um asset prices. Uh, we are seeing the S&P and ASX reaching relatively higher levels than before. Um, we are seeing generally improved flows
1:21
across the listed asset managers over the June quarter and the March quarter, while the wealth management platforms, um, are also seeing, uh, flows recovering in a cyclical manner towards the second half of FY 24. Um, you know, that's it. You know, I think we hear some asset managers saying, you know, they are there's record money on the sidelines, uh, waiting to be redeployed in the stocks, uh, From what we see, the benefit this benefit may be exaggerated because I think the data shows a fair bit
1:55
of the institutional rebalancing activity has already happened. Um, where in the past there's too much cash, not enough bonds or not enough stocks, uh, in the portfolios. But now the proportions are much more balanced. So I think fund managers can't really depend much on rebalancing anymore. I think the challenge is for them to continue to outperform and to try to source money that's currently in bank accounts or term deposits, you know, but, you know, to conclude, overall, the outflow is still quite sorry. The outlook is still quite fickle and tied to interest rate expectations. If the tonality of interest rates get worse, such as if inflation is stickier and if central banks changed their tone, then we would likely see asset prices, uh, fall again and sentiment soften again, which would then affect flows. Yeah, it's interesting, Sean, because we're at that point where of course, the Australian market following global markets higher, um, taking out new records of course, just recently. But as you've
2:55
alluded to there, the interest rate picture may be somewhat different here in Australia with the prospects that the reserve Bank could in fact lift rates again. So we are very much behind the curve, if you will, compared with other global banks. How then is that likely to you think affect those inflows, particularly for those listed managers?
3:14
Well, I would say that, um, many, many active managers in Australia, not just source money from Australian based investors. Um, a fair bit of them have, um, you know, money invested across global global equities, you know, more diversified fund managers, for example. Um, like we see like the more popular ones for uh, would be, uh, pinnacle and GQ. I believe that today's prices say for pinnacle. It has a diversified portfolio of, you know, asset managers, uh, with uncorrelated asset classes that don't really cannibalize each other. Um, the business model is more resilient because, uh, you see the lack of coordination over here means that when some funds underperform, others should outperform, which helps to attract steadier flows. Um, another listed active manager in Australia that we see that is going gangbusters is JC G. Um, it is currently riding the wave of current outperformance. You know, while the growth would go on for some time, I
4:14
think investors should remember the past lessons with Magellan and avoid chasing the momentum and buying the stock at a high price. So I guess, you know, to just summarize it, it's not just I don't think that the, the, the flow trajectory is affected solely by the ASX buy by the Australian, by Australia's interest rates. I think you know very much the market needs to flow, uh, with what um, the global markets are seeing. Um, and I think that over time, although Australia is behind the curve, I think eventually the rich should follow suit alongside its global counterparts.