Sign inJoin free

Watch / Economic data

How high rates are changing Aussie spending trends

16 July 20247:10

How high rates are changing Aussie spending trends

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Key points:

  • There was a 0.6% increase in the Household Spending Insights Index for June

  • Australians are spending more on essential services and less on discretionary items

  • Stephen Halmarick contemplates on the RBA's consideration of this data for their decision to raise interest rates

Stephen Halmarick, Chief Economist at Commonwealth Bank (ASX: CBA) discusses the recent rise in the Household Spending Insights Index, which saw 0.6% growth for June following a 0.7% increase in May. Despite a majority of the 12 spending categories showing an upturn, it was predominantly three areas - recreation, hospitality and food, and beverage - that drove the advance. Stephen remarks on the increase in the recreation sector, specifically in holiday bookings, despite showing merely a 0.2% increase in the year to June.

Further, he highlights that Australians are spending more on essential services and less on discretionary items, a trend that continues to persist. Sectors like insurance, utilities, health, and education witnessed the most considerable rise, while household goods maintain a steady decrease. Stephen believes the data discloses a significant divide between essential and discretionary spending while being particularly hard on renters compared to homeowners or those with a mortgage.

Lastly, Stephen comments on how the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) might interpret this data pertaining to their decision on whether to raise interest rates or not. He sees younger people and those renting bearing the brunt of the economy. CPI, employment numbers, and the inflation story also come under Stephen's purview as he speculates on a November rate cut, where Australia could join a global trend alongside the ECB, Bank of Canada, Bank of England, US Federal Reserve, and the Reserve Bank of New Zealand.

Full unedited transcript below:

0:00

Well. The Commonwealth Bank Household Spending Insights Index was out late last week, and it showed an improvement ever so slightly for the month of June. So let's find out what's behind that and actually what it means, of course, about the Australian economy. And for that, chief economist Stephen Hammack joins me in the studio. Stephen, welcome back to us. Thank you. Pleasure. Thank you. So yeah, it seems counterintuitive that we saw this household spending index lift. Yeah. So it was up 0.6% for the month of June. That followed an increase of 0.7% in May, although the main number was revised down a little bit and the annual growth rate is 3.9% and it was 4% in May. So a pretty flat. But there's 12 different categories we look at. And eight of the 12 spending categories went up in June. But really only three of them contributed to the increase. So that was recreation hospitality and food and beverage. So I thought, you know what's going on in there. And if you look at particularly at recreation,

0:59

was the strongest increase in the month, that was like holiday bookings. But in the year to June recreation is up just 0.2%. So let's call it flat. So there was a bit of an increase in June, but over the year really very flat. And and that's nominal dollar. So after inflation it's you know it's negative. And this um this trend where we're having to spend more money on essential services and less on discretionary items is definitely continuing. So in the year to June, the biggest increases in spending on things like insurance, that's up nearly 9% in the year. Utilities, health, education and less money on things like household goods. Yeah, well, everybody at home watching is nodding their head because we've all seen our bills coming in. Yeah. So this is a treasure trove of information. I mean, this is literally money that's going through Commonwealth Bank accounts and credit and everything else. So what to you is the most interesting part of it or the most meaningful. So a couple of things I think just that that big split between the

1:59

essentials and the discretionary. So apart from household goods, things like communication and digital and household services, uh, you know, really quite soft. Um, we can also break it down by home ownership status. So I've only been doing that for around three or so months, and it's really showing that people that are renting are really doing it a lot tougher than those with a mortgage, and certainly a lot tougher than those who own their own home outright. So. So spending by renters is actually down 0.9% year to June. And again, that's nominal dollars. So in real terms would be, uh, down, you know, quite significantly those that those were the mortgage spendings increasing about 1.5% per annum. And those who own their own home outright, more than 2%. So it's um, you know, the if you like, the burden of the adjustment on the economy is really being unevenly distributed. And, uh, generally younger people, um, or lower income that are, that are renting are definitely doing

2:59

it the toughest. Yeah. So it's have have nots but it's also demographics story as well. Largely. Yeah. So how is the RBA reading this data. Yeah. Well so so we we provide the RBA with all the data once it's once it's published. So I think it would go into their thought process that um, you know the decision in August to whether to raise interest rates or not. Again. Um, you know they'll be very conscious that if they if they do raise rates again and we might talk about the CPI coming up, uh, you know, the burden of the adjustment is really going to be felt on a, on a narrow group of people. Um, essentially younger people that are, that are renting is the biggest burden. And, you know, so I think that'll be a big part of the decision making process. And they've already pulled back on their spending and they've already how many more can they pull back. That's right. So they're already already are pulling back. You know how much more kind of like pain uh, is required in that, in that sector. Um, so yeah, it's a big decision for the bank. Yeah.

3:59

What though what can we read into the inflation story by this data? Because just by, you know, having to spend more and more on insurance and education, I mean, those are those are inflationary costs. Uh, they are in the, the inflationary costs that are almost irrespective of the level of interest rates. Right. So insurance utilities, you know, these are well known. You know, clearly the government is now providing some support on the utility front with the electricity rebates, uh, you know, health education. Um, so there's not much that the level of interest rates can do to, to affect those sectors. So the question then is whether the reserve Bank feels like they need to, you know, put more burden of the adjustment on the other parts of the economy to bring the average inflation rate down when there's some sectors that are. Uh, you know, price increases, uh, irrespective of the level of rates, do you think that they would be feeling that, I presume? No, because I don't think that you've changed your. No. So our base case is no increase in rates in August. But having said that, you know, there's

4:59

two data points between now and that August board meeting that are going to be critical. So employment numbers on Thursday. Yep. Um, so we're expecting a small increase of about 20,000 in employment. That won't be enough to stop the unemployment rate moving up from 4% to 4.1. Uh, and then of course, the big numbers are the 31st of July, the CPI. So we're looking for 0.9% on the quarter for the headline rate. Uh, that will give you an annual rate around three, seven, three eight. We think at that level, it's not high enough for them to tighten again in August. You really get it in the number, you know, above 1% per quarter. Uh, for the RBI to feel like they need to tighten around about 4% annual. But I think that's a it's a big call because when we get to the September quarter CPI, which is out at the end of October, we're likely to see the headline inflation rate under 3%. And that's within the 2 to 3% band. So why why are you confident that we'll see it pull back to

5:58

within that target band this year? Well, so partly that's the electricity rebates and other government policies at work. So there'll be this gap open up between the underlying rate, the trimmed mean which will stay in the high threes, and the headline rate which will be in the high twos. So that's going to make life a bit more challenging for the reserve Bank I think. Mhm. So um you believe higher for longer though. You know this patience narrative or are you still calling for cutting. Yeah. So our base case is still a November rate cut. And if we think about that as I mentioned, the September quarter CPI out at the end of October, um, we think we'll show the headline rate under 3%, or even if it is being sort of engineered by government rebates and said, yes, but I think it's important to realize that that that lower headline rate then feeds into other prices, anything that indexed to the headline inflation rate. And we know that, uh, the wages growth numbers look like they've peaked. Consumer spending is pretty soft. And by November, we think

6:58

that not only has the ECB and the Bank of Canada eased, but so has the Bank of England, the US Federal Reserve and the reserve Bank of New Zealand so Australia could join that global trend.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy