How do you price a ceasefire?
How do you price a ceasefire?
About this video
Key points:
Iran seen as negotiating from a position of retained leverage, not surrender
US and Iranian ceasefire plans are viewed as incompatible, implying likely US concessions
Iran's Revolutionary Guard is seen as consolidating power, hardening Iran’s strategic posture
Iran’s nuclear enrichment know‑how is considered intact despite military strikes
Oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz are expected to face lasting disruption and bottlenecks
Madison Cartwright from the Commonwealth Bank outlines a highly uncertain outlook for the proposed two‑week ceasefire between the United States and Iran, suggesting negotiations are being shaped by asymmetric leverage rather than capitulation. Cartwright notes that Iran continues to launch missiles and drones while retaining control of the Strait of Hormuz, arguing this underpins Tehran’s ten‑point plan, including sanctions relief, continued nuclear enrichment and effective control of the strategic waterway.
Cartwright views the US fifteen‑point proposal and Iran’s position as largely incompatible, implying Washington may need to grant concessions and accept a less favourable deal than before the conflict. The Revolutionary Guard is seen as the key winner inside Iran after multiple decapitation strikes, with a younger, more hardline cohort consolidating influence and marginalising relatively more moderate figures. Cartwright points to public disagreements between the president and the Guard as evidence of ongoing internal fragmentation, but still sees the Guard as the firmest power centre.
On nuclear issues, Cartwright argues Iran’s human capital and dispersed research network mean enrichment capability endures despite damaged facilities. Even if oil flows resume through the Strait of Hormuz, Cartwright expects damaged infrastructure, disrupted wells and new toll or tax mechanisms to keep supplies below pre‑war levels for an extended period.