Don't misread what a Fed cut could mean
About this video
Key points:
Mabrouk expresses a view that the market has potentially overreacted to US economic data.
Market expectations for rate cuts being too high are leading to potential disappointments.
A predicted 50 basis point cut from the Federal Reserve in September could lead to misinterpretation and excessive reactions on the equity market. Mabrouk also predicts possible further cuts by the Bank of England and the European Central Bank.
Mabrouk Chetouane from Natixis Investment Managers puts forth the view that the market may have overreacted when it comes to U.S. economic data. He specifically references the ISM service, the job report, and suggests that the presumption of a collapsing US economy has been rapidly dismissed. Mabrouk accentuates that it's premature to conclude that the US economy has entered into recession, expressing scepticism about corresponding empirical rules, particularly within the context of the pandemic.
Mabrouk goes on to flag the potential for disappointment, arguing that market expectations of rate cuts might be unequally high. He highlights a concern that the market may not be factoring in the non-linear environment created by the pandemic, and notes that the Federal Reserve isn't likely to change its monetary policy based on one poor job report. One crucial point Mabrouk makes is the importance of not battling the Federal Reserve's decisions, but instead, trusting and heeding their guidance.
Finally, Mabrouk shares his perspective on the potential for a 50 basis point cut from the Federal Reserve in September. He expresses that if something like this happens, it should not be interpreted as positive news, though it could easily be misread by the market. He forewarns of the dangerous potential for excessive reactions on the equity market in such a case, describing the potential message as not being particularly positive when relating to the US business cycle. Mabrouk concludes by forecasting the possibility of additional 25 basis point cuts from the Bank of England and the European Central Bank should situational conditions continue to deteriorate.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
So let's get another view on this bout of volatility. My next guest says the market may have overreacted to U.S. economic data. He's not alone in that view. So let's get thinking. Maybe Chetan from Natixis Investment Managers joins me now. Hi. Nice to have you. Brooke, welcome to the program once again. So, um, look, now we're through this bout of volatility. Uh, hindsight's 2020, right? But did the weight of the data. So the jobless claims, the nonfarm payroll report and that ISM manufacturing report, did it deserve any of the consternation it caused in markets?
0:45
Hello. Thank you for the invitation and this opportunity. So I think and as you said, I mean the market has overreacted this I mean, really after these readings that we had last week on the ISM, on the job report. And when it comes into if we take the example of the ISM service, for example, definitely amend the Did of the recession of a collapsing US economy has been clearly set aside. And this is not I mean, one point is not a trend, as I used to say, as you used to say, because the fed will not mean change is tense in terms of monetary policy just after one and single and disappointing job report. I mean very more they need even more data, more confidence about in this, uh, the, the scenario of the soft landing. And definitely this is why I mean, we need to wait and the market has to be patient before seeing a clear signal that the fed is ready to cut to cut interest rates and clear signals about them
1:45
in a declining US economy. But so far, it's too soon to make any clear conclusions on that front. The US economy is clearly slow down, and there is no I mean, I think discussion about this, but we cannot say at this stage that the US economy has entered into a recession. We can see many comments about these, some empirical rules saying that the US economy has entered into this recessionary territory. But obviously, in my opinion, uh, these empirical rules are not I mean, taking into account, I mean, the, the, this non-linear environment in which we are, since, I mean, we have left them in this, uh, pandemic situation. Yeah. So but it's, it's different when you talk about what the market should have done to what the market actually did do. Right. So do you think there could be some aftershocks coming from this most recent bout of volatility?
2:40
Yeah. And this is the problem of this situation because I mean the markets were expecting, they used to expect I mean very much from central banks. I mean you do remember what happened in last December when Jay Powell said, okay, we are thinking about lowering interest rates and the market has suddenly priced, uh, 66 cuts for, uh, for the, for the you for the fed, uh, for 2024. Of course it was exaggerated. And this scenario is taking place again because we're seeing many rate cuts priced in by the markets. But obviously, again, it can only trigger disappointment from the market. And this is I mean the risk of this situation because expectation can go can go very far. And obviously the market could be disappointed. And this is something that we used to to, to to live with the market because this is how would they behave. This is how the investors are betting against I mean the fed. But as I again used to say, don't fight the fed. We need to trust them. We need to
3:40
listen to them and they will guide them in the market and they will anchor the expectations. So many expectations in the market priced in. But of course, this will be, uh, the reason an excuse, I mean, for this after FX shock because I mean many disappointment expected by the year end.
4:00
So 50 basis point cut in September. If that comes to fruition, would that be an admission in your view that the fed kept rates at too high for too long? Would it be some sort of an emergency reaction, or is it just too early to tell?
4:19
Well, I think if that deliver 50 basis point red card in September, while I mean the consensus and the scenario is a 25 basis point credit card, this will be not this could not be interpreted as a good news because it will mean, as you said, that the fed is behind the curve and the US economy is seriously a man experiencing. I mean, the magnitude of the of the of the, of the slowdown is more, uh, more more important than expected. So definitely, uh, these kind of, let's say surprise if there is no, I mean, clear communication about I mean, this, uh, red cut in September 20th 5 or 50 basis point could be misinterpreted by the market and they could trigger again uh, excessive and overreaction, excessive reactions. Uh, on the on the, on the, on the equity market. So this is a bit dangerous. I mean, to, uh, expect 50 basis points because, again, the message will not be extremely positive. Uh, when it comes to the US
5:19
business cycle, it means that it is suffering more than expected. More than the more than the the fed is seeing. So and they need to deliver more and they need to deliver in emergency mode, which is not a good news, definitely for the equity market and for the risky asset from a global perspective.
5:37
Well, there is so much to think about, especially in the global context of rates. You know, here it looks as if we won't get any type of a cut, at least to, you know, by December, by Christmas. But you reckon we still could have cuts coming from the ECB, the BOE, the BOC, you know, that will sort of be out of lockstep with the rest of the world.
5:59
Well, I think again, the central banks, they are I mean they try them into to pilot the, the the expectation. They try to anchor these expectations. Well when it comes to the ECB, when it comes to the BOE, we are surprised let's say in August by lowering their interest rates. The ECB has delivered already in June. What we can say is that it is not impossible to see them in all these central banks. I mean, um, being I mean, organising their red cards, I mean, in a synchronized way in September or maybe later. But definitely what we can expect is an additional 25 basis basis point red card for the BOE for the ECB, and may be more if the situation is deteriorating. But when we look at the data in Europe, I mean, if we I mean, of course, Germany is in a very, let's say, not good situation, but the UK, I mean, there is I mean good data coming from the, from the, from the, from the, from the economy and inflation is still there. Same thing for, for the
6:59
Europe, a European economy. Inflation is sticky. We have main issues with with the labor market. So data dependent is clearly the new mantra of the central banks and the need, I mean more information, more data to make sure that they are delivering in the right. Um, let's say size for their interest rate, interest rate, red card. Sorry. So 25 basis point A is the most likely scenario. Another 25 basis point is most likely scenario for the BOE and for the ECB.