Crisis Management: When female CEOs are brought in to clean up the mess
Crisis Management: When female CEOs are brought in to clean up the mess
About this video
Key Topics:
Executive exodus in Australian media companies
Appointment of female CEOs during crises
Governance challenges at the ASX, including technology and transparency
Helen Bird from Swinburne University talks about the recent trend of executives stepping down in Australian media companies due to poor financial performance and governance issues. She highlights the case of Channel Nine (ASX: NEC), where claims of bullying and harassment have surfaced, shedding light on organisational toxicity.,
Helen discusses the habitual appointment of female CEOs during crises, often as a last resort when male counterparts avoid the 'poisoned chalice'. She notes that while this offers opportunities for women, it also imposes significant challenges and responsibilities on them in problem-riddled companies.
Lastly, Helen shares insights on the Australian Securities Exchange's (ASX) new leadership facing complex issues such as the technological revamp and regulatory relationships. She stresses the importance of technological expertise on the board and the need for immediate attention to governance and transparency.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
Let's get into corporate governance, shall we? I always look forward to these chats with Helen Bird. Let's talk about, well, the latest in the media landscape. Helen Bird, senior lecturer at Swinburne University, joins me now. Helen, welcome to the program. Is there something in the water at these Aussie media companies with Mike sneesby, I should say the latest to to step down on Friday.
0:26
Well, it is interesting because it marks a line of them going and of course he's not the only one and nor is it just limited to listed companies. The ABC also recently lost its head as well. But there's something going on in terms of if the listed companies a reminder that, um, the financial performance of them has not been strong, the price of their shares have dropped off. So all those things do play a part and we shouldn't underrate that. But from a governance angle, there is another theme. And uh, from channel nine, at least, there was bullying claims. There have been sexual harassment claims. And there's also been a suggestion of some kind of cover up at a toxic culture inside the workplace. So, um, those things weren't new and no one needs to be responsible for them. But in a sense, he was two years in the job before these things came to light. And what seems to be occurring a lot in these organizations where senior officers are going isn't so much the event as it's discovery. It's almost as if they
1:26
are taking a hit, very delayed, or having kept it quiet or having when it does come to attention, the subject of national attention and embarrassment for the company, and there's a real loss of confidence in their in their management of the company. And we see that in channel nine. Now, channel nine has quite a way to go to fix up its problems and has acknowledged as such. And we can say more about that. But yes, in answer to your question, I think that is the issue that I can see occurring. And there's quite a bit of it across the media companies at the moment. Okay. So Amanda Lang
1:58
is being touted as, you know, potential for the CEO role. And even in the newsroom we were chatting after he stepped down saying, oh, I bet they bring in a woman to fix things up. Not only because it appears as if and this is allegedly nine has a woman problem. But oftentimes, Helen, correct me if I'm wrong. You get a woman in to fix the mess that's been left before. What? What gives there? Well, it is so true. Um, and yes, you're right to comment on that from a number of angles. Um, I guess the one exception to that was Optus, where the replacement CEO was a man and he was fixing problems that occurred under the first female CEO. So it doesn't always work. But there does seem to be a habit when things are bad of appointing female CEOs. And yes, it is about fixing the mess and it is often a poisoned chalice for the CEO involved. But I guess what really that tells you is that no male CEO would do it. And so in a sense, that opens
2:57
the door for opportunity for women, but they're often comes at a cost. And that's what you're looking on at channel nine. And the enormous task involved, you'd have to ask what brave person would take this on? And obviously they found one in a female.
3:12
Well, whoever gets the job, I wish them well, obviously when it comes, because there's been a lot of shareholder value, um, really lost. Uh. Okay, so we've got a new chair at the ASX. This chair will inevitably have to still deal with the chest replacement system. Um, what what other sort of challenges will this chair likely be facing in terms of governance issues? Um, well, the thing about the chess replacement system is that it's also a signal to the fact they have to have special licences to operate both as a, as a market operator and also the chess system itself. And that requires them to interact with ASIC, the corporate regulator, and the reserve Bank, and in particular the reserve Bank undertakes a review of the way they've run the business every year and produces quite a detailed report. So these are things that are essentially public or interest obligations because they're running a piece of infrastructure that is used by the public, and it's that kind of thing that's sort of essentiality
4:12
of what they do, coupled with the fact that it is something which affects the wealth of every Australian, if it's not run properly, makes it more than just running a company. It's a pretty significant concern. And so the question mark over the new CEO, a new chair, although apparently with a wealth of experience and running other ASX companies, is have they had that kind of degree of experience in that kind of highly regulated industry, where the real identity of the parties involved is important and relationships with the regulator are critical, and those are the things that are not entirely clear from from the appointment or those. I want to say that the proposed new chair does have a wealth of experience. The second thing that's not entirely clear to me is what experience that chair has in relation to technology. And one of the things that's really come home as the scandal involving chess is that the ASX is a digitally dependent company, so it is all about technology, critical understanding of technology. And there's a
5:12
slate of technology projects at, uh, at the ASX. So technology governance is going to be absolutely critical. It's been done very poorly. And that's not necessarily something Mr. Clarke has vast experience at, although I'll stand corrected. Well, but what about the makeup of the rest of the board, because they've been there through some of this debacle that has been the chess replacement. If he doesn't have necessarily the deep technological experience, I mean, would history prove that they do?
5:41
Well, the board itself, a president following on from the debacle in 2022, the ASX appointed a technology transformation expert to the board. And he said, I what's called a technology committee, and that's sort of supposed to be managing risk and also observing the the management of those projects. Now that's still in place. But nobody else on the board appeared to have any of the requisite experience to understand what they were doing. And the question might well be asked, is that enough? Can one expert hope to achieve and manage all of the problems that have been identified, let alone any new ones that come from new projects. So there is, I think, a call to really have a hard look at the ASX board. I think in defence, the ASX board has said they have been in the throes of replacing directors and they point to Wayne Byres, the former head of APRA, as one of their new appointments. But Wayne doesn't come with any special knowledge of technology either. So I think that question is I think more work could be done on that front. I know they say they're in transition to a new board, but I
6:41
think it is something that they can't leave to occur over a long period. It needs to be attended to now. And I note there are two rather well qualified candidates who put their names up to the ASX to be considered for director of election, and I'm hoping the shareholders of the ASX are having a good, hard look at those directors and are considering their appointment. Okay, um, Helen, what, if any, are key themes that we might see emerge from this upcoming AGM season? Because that will be what we're talking about very shortly. Well, from the governance point of view, of course, you'll always see things about profitability, margins and deals. But from my angle, I see two things that are kind of critical. Uh, firstly, I see the issue being about what we're paying our executives, what their entitlements and, and in particular, um, what sort of bonuses we're giving. And I think we need to tie those much more effectively to criteria for performance ever more than before. And I think if we have a look at organisations such as Vanguard, they're doing that. They're
7:41
insisting on better explanation and accountability for how those bonuses are earned. And I think that's really quite critical. Um, and the second thing I think we're looking at is, is essentially, um, the make sure that there are clear disclosure to the, uh, to both the shareholders and generally to the market on all of the decisions that are being made by the company and the reasons for them. Um, at this present point in time, um, that's not a specific criticism so much as a concern. There are some important things going underway at the moment and a need for companies to explain their position on them.