China's singles day shopping drives consumption recovery
About this video
In a recent analysis of the Chinese market turnovers, Catherine Yeung, from Fidelity International, identifies a positive shift in consumer confidence despite ongoing economic struggles. Catherine notes the success of the Singles Day shopping event hosted by Alibaba and JD, both recording an increase in gross merchandise value and order volumes.
Pointing to this as an emerging confidence in the Chinese growth story, she places a significant emphasis on the high household savings rate and manageable debts in comparison to other countries., Catherine highlights the consolidation of state-owned developers within the property market despite ongoing struggles with private developers. She foresees a wealth of upcoming retail sales, credit, and liquidity data playing an essential role in determining the sustainability of growth recovery.
Concerning the economy's position, Catherine identifies a promising trend, indicated by the increasing demand for luxury and low-end brands, leaving a murky outlook for mid-price range brands.
Looking towards the geopolitical landscape, Catherine brings attention to upcoming talks between President Xi and Biden during the APEC meeting. She underlines the interdependent trade relationship between the two nations as vital despite foreseeable obstacles. As discussions between the two leaders may induce market volatility, Catherine recommends cautious optimism and discussion outcomes being key for the market.
She remarks on the flow of investments into China, noting a surge of inflows from foreign and domestic investors while cautioning about the steep valuations of markets like India.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
Internationally. China very much in focus. This week just held its annual 24 hour online shopping event and Saturday Singles Day. South Korea's expectations for the festival, which is viewed as a gauge of consumer confidence, was subdued this year as the economy struggles to recover for more. Catherine Yeung joining us from Fidelity International. Catherine, very good to catch up with you again. All right. So do we have the data out? It's just how Singles Day transpired.
0:30
Sure. So Singles Day finished on midnight on Saturday. And so both Alibaba's Tmall as well as JD's online platform, they both recorded an increase in terms of gross merchandise value, what we call GMV participating users, and order and also order volume. So really a sign or an indication that we are seeing confidence resume when it comes to the consumption story, which is obviously key for overall Chinese growth. All right then as we head towards Christmas and beyond, then what trends are you seeing? Is that likely to be sustainable do you think?
1:10
Well, we hope so. I mean, again, when we look at the household savings rate, it's over 35%. So that's really, really key. We don't see households having the same kind of debt issues as other countries around the world, including Australia. The property market again, it's not about a solution in terms of lower interest rates because again, households can pay back their mortgages. It's more again, going back to that confidence argument, the issue about confidence, especially with the developers. So we're likely to see again this continued struggle with some of the private developers. But within the sector, the state owned developers themselves are taking up a lot of the projects. So it's going to become a very consolidated space. And then this week we've also got retail sales, as well as a lot of data relating to credit and liquidity, which is also really, really key in terms of an indication of whether there's growth and the expectations of the data trough in the third quarter where this growth recovery is sustainable. Yeah. You refer to that data dump we're getting mid-week for
2:09
October sales, production, investment jobs. Katherine,
2:14
what's your reading of where the economy is at? Is it past that trough then
2:19
it feels like it, especially when you speak to the companies and, you know, on the ground when you when you when you talk about sentiment. So for example, in our Shanghai office where the building is located, you know, there's big cues still in terms of the luxury brands. So whether it's Louis Vuitton or Gucci. And so what we're seeing from a consumer perspective is that the low end priced brands are doing well. The luxury brands are recovering. That middle bit is still a bit murky. So all in all, you know, again, from an investment perspective, the fundamentals of companies for many, many companies across many industries looks very attractive. Valuations are so incredibly cheap that as long as we see an earnings recovery in terms of a rerating of earnings, and as long as we continue to see this economic recovery, not a V-shaped recovery, but this continuation in terms of better data, then this bodes well for next year. Catherine, this comes as we've got this forthcoming meeting between President XI and President Biden
3:16
on the sidelines of the APEC meeting. What can we expect, do you think diplomatically? Obviously, there are a lot of hurdles, but also as this pans out, particularly for trade between the two countries.
3:31
Trade wise. I mean, they're very important to each other. You know, we've just seen Nvidia announced that they're creating a different chip because Nvidia's products, some of them were banned in terms of China. And so they're now creating just to show you again how important the Chinese customer, whether it's companies or the end consumer, are to many, many foreign companies. And likewise, you know, it's not just going to be consumption that drives the Chinese growth story. China's still quite dependent in terms of demand, global demand in terms of exports. And so again, whilst the relationship between the US and China is going to continue to be very competitive, it's been like this for many, many years and is likely to remain in place. So again, I wouldn't completely write off in terms of no further market volatility given geopolitics, but it's definitely a move in the right direction in terms of XI Jinping and Biden meeting this week. Do you feel as though we're going to see any sort of demands or concessions made?
4:30
Probably probably more concessions. And again, it's the outcome of the rhetoric which is going to be key for the markets. All right. Now of course, this brings us to on that backdrop, as far as investors are concerned and how investable China is at the moment, what are we seeing particularly as far as inflows are concerned.
4:50
So inflows mean it should be no surprise that China is really seen no positive inflows, both from foreign investors this year as well as interestingly from the domestic investors. So in fact, a lot of foreigners are looking at the direction of domestic flows as an indicator to get back potentially into the market. So whilst we've seen negative flows into China, Japan and India have really reaped the inflows coming into the region. Now again, when we look at both Japan and India, some interesting and very attractive investment cases for both markets and the underlying companies. But you really have to look at where valuations are trading. And India I mean they're steep. They're trading at about 40 times forward price earnings. When you have a market in China trading at about nine times. And so it feels like there's no risk being factored into those valuations. We have an election next year. And again nothing goes up in a straight line. So I would be cognizant or cautious at just how fast that market's gone up. And we tend to have a bit of a pear trade between
5:50
India and China, a bit like BHP and Rio and Australia. So as you see China recover, if it does recover and you know, in an appropriate manner, you could see some of those those flows going back into China from the likes of India. Yes. So what's going to need to change meaningfully for investor sentiment to change in regard to China then do you feel. I think it's going to be this continuation of just seeing the data points come through. And as we've been talking about over the months, it's also about resetting expectations. When it comes to China. You know, making money in China isn't going to be as easy as it was in 2019 or 2020. By owning a few names and like a couple of sectors, it's going to be very much about identifying the opportunities on a case by case basis. And even, you know, China doesn't need to grow at nine, 10% anymore. That's going to be India. That is going to be the growth giant of Asia. And so we have to take that into consideration. So growth itself is going to be more moderate but a lot more sustainable. And I think that's really really key for the long term. So China is basically changing. And we should also think about how we change in terms of how we look at the
6:49
country.