Sign inJoin free

Watch / China

China's demand-side problem

12 July 20249:27

China's demand-side problem

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Key points:

  • The plenum will likely drive China's focus on developing the supply side

  • The rural-urban divide poses a challenge for China's government

  • US-China relations under a possible Trump presidency could affect China's economic growth

Duncan Wrigley, chief economist of Pantheon Macroeconomics, views the upcoming plenum as a key moment for China's economy. He expects the focus to be on supply-side policies such as advanced manufacturing, innovation success sectors and new industries like self-driving vehicles and advanced chips. However, the challenge lies in prompting the demand side to improve household incomes and consumption, although such reforms are deemed less likely.

The rural-urban divide also presents an issue in China's economic development. Duncan paints the picture of city governments, mired in high debt levels, struggling to accommodate the influx of migrants from rural areas seeking better opportunities. Borrowing insights from existing pilot schemes, such as one in Jiang Province, he recommends encouraging tourism to rural areas and promoting ecommerce to enhance rural income and spur economic activity.

Duncan also discusses the influence of emerging sectors like advanced chips and AI on China's economy. Despite US restrictions on China's access to most advanced chips, he still expresses optimism about China's internet companies like Tencent, Alibaba, and JD. Unfortunately, the potential for further US-China friction under another Trump presidency could hinder progress. Duncan postulates a more confrontational approach from the US, leading to a rise in tariffs and a unilateral approach in geopolitics.

Full unedited transcript below:

0:00

Well, we've discussed, of course, the very important week that it is in China. Next week, let's get more on the plenum. What to expect in the data out of China. Duncan Wrigley from Pantheon Macroeconomics joins me now. I just wanted to ask you as well about some of the data that we've seen out of China, particularly when it comes to exports, those trade figures. What sort of a picture is it painting?

0:24

Exports are relatively strong for for China right now, certainly compared with domestic demand. Um, you know, in June, the the headline figure was slightly higher, but that's largely to with base effects, um, strong growth of demand and exports to Asean, quite weak to the EU, US somewhere in between. Um, so you know that that's a big picture. Exports are helping to support China's economy. But on the other side of things, imports were a bit weaker than the market expected. There was a falling crude oil imports, um, slowing demand for copper imports. You know, some of that is to do with perhaps seasonal factors. June sees very extreme weather, heavy rain in China. But it also is reflective of, you know, what we're seeing still is a kind of sluggish, underwhelming domestic demand picture. Yeah, as you say, of course the imports picture then potentially pointing to more stimulus. The plenum, the third

1:24

plenum coming up next week may not necessarily actually outline stimulus, but they are trying to get a growth plan there. What is the conundrum given there's also, of course, debt levels.

1:38

Right. I think the what we are certainly going to see next week at the the third plenum has been quite heavily, uh, highlighted is a push to develop the supply side. So that means advanced manufacturing, promoting innovation success sectors like electric vehicles, there'll be new sectors that China's policy makers will be promoting, like self-driving vehicles and more advanced chips. All that stuff is very clear. You know what is less certain? And, you know, the optimists are hoping for. Some of the economists have also been promoting to China's leaders. Is it a reform to promote the demand side, in other words, to boost household incomes, to boost household consumption? Uh, broaden the welfare net transfers from state assets in effect to private households and individuals in order to spur that side of the economy. Um, you know, we don't know for sure there might be a positive surprise, but I

2:38

think base case is that set of reforms is is going to be less likely. So, um, instead, what we're going to see are, uh, you know, pushing forward on some of these structural reforms on, on demand, on supply side and manufacturing in terms of, I guess, trying to lessen the urban rural divide as well. Um, how do you think, um, authorities are really going to try and achieve this?

3:05

Yeah, we can see some clues. Uh, in in what's already been done in regional pilot schemes. Um, so, for example, in Giang Province, which is near Shanghai on the eastern, eastern coastline, that's been put forward as a pilot scheme for this kind of area. What we see are a couple of things. So one is, uh, for city governments that have the finances to afford it, they allow more migrants from rural areas to come in, enjoy or take take advantage of local public services like health, education on the same terms as local people, so that that is the, uh, the most positive area. But the issue is most cities don't have the finances to afford it. As you're mentioning, debt levels are very high. Um, there are a number of regions, especially central, western and north east China, that are really struggling with finances in the economy. They can't really afford to do this kind of reform. Uh, the other plank that we are seeing, um, in in Jiang Province, that

4:05

pilot area I mentioned are, are kind of quite pragmatic things. So to to in order to boost the incomes or of rural people. Um, what we see are promoting things like tourism by people from the cities coming to the countryside, setting up new tourism sites and also e-commerce, opening up the logistics, the transport networks to allow people in, in the farms, in the villages to sell more easily their products directly to relatively well-off people in the cities. It's likely there's going to be a lot of focus on AI as well. We're talking the likelihood of visions of flying cars and the like. How is this plenum important? And I guess differing from ones in the past. And you think about back to 2013, when the focus was, I guess, on increasing the the one child policy or getting rid of the one child policy. It's kind of a very different, um, theme this year potentially.

5:04

Yes. I think, um, this year the theme will be pushing forward into some of these, uh, emerging sectors, as you mentioned. I very much at the forefront of, uh, businesses and, and the government in China. Um, you know, the issue for China is obviously the US has put restrictions on China's access to the most advanced chips used in, in, uh, generating AI models. Uh, China has still secured a number of these chips earlier on before the restrictions came in. But, you know, getting the most advanced chips, um, is is blocked by, by these US restrictions. So, you know, this is one, uh, major obstacle for, for China to be at the absolute forefront of AI development. That said, I will say that China's internet companies have a good track record in terms of taking the latest technology. In the past, it

6:04

was e-commerce or other internet applications, uh, you know, fintech and applying it in a way that is very consumer friendly and therefore generating good business from it. So I'm fairly optimistic that we might well see, uh, China's internet companies, the, the, the likes of Tencent, um, Alibaba, JD, you know, being fairly innovative in a pragmatic application, uh, approach to applying AI in a way that consumers like. Um, and yes, there's a there's a whole bunch of next generation, uh, industries emerging. You know, we're seeing already trials for self-driving cars in a number of big cities in China. Um, you know, not without some issues for for sure. There was an I think a pedestrian got killed at an accident in Wuhan, uh, the the other day. So they have to wrestle with some of those kind of legal insurance. Who's going to take responsibility for that?

7:04

Is it the car company? You know, is it the, uh, the owner of the cars? All these kind of issues which, um, are affecting the development of self-driving cars globally are starting to come into China first. But I think we will see China pushing ahead with, uh, this sector, perhaps, you know, at the forefront of, uh, of global development. They're, of course, really just trying to point themselves into that position of being, at one point, the world's most valuable and profitable or biggest economy in terms of the country that currently holds that title. How do you think geopolitical politics is going to play through into any relations with China, given we could be facing another Trump presidency.

7:51

Well that is. Yeah, that that does seem to have quite a high likelihood. Um, now, if we have another Trump presidency, um, you know, who who can guess exactly what he is likely to do, but it's more, you know, I think we can say it's going to be a more confrontational approach. Um, um, a much more direct approach to by the US, um, taking on some of the, the issues where, uh, Trump sees China to be intruding on, you know, he's already talked about much higher tariffs. Um, you know, China's exports to the US have already fallen a lot. So, you know, there will be some effect, but maybe not as much effect as back in 2018. Um, and then more broadly, in terms of geopolitics, it's um, the what was one of the last Trump presidency was a very kind of unilateral approach. So the US pursuing its interests without,

8:52

uh, so much cooperation with its allies in Europe and Asia. Um, so we might get more of that again. And, you know, it does lay open the possibility that that Trump might also, in some areas, kind of do a deal with China, uh, perhaps in some geopolitical areas. I mean, this is this is possible based on his, his track record in the past. Um, but I think overall, the, the US attitude towards China under a possible Trump presidency will be, uh, more overtly hostile and disruptive.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy