Sign inJoin free

Watch / China

China providing inflexion point for commodities

22 Nov 20239:11

China providing inflexion point for commodities

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Gary Ng from Natixis, shares his views on the ongoing upheavals in China's property sector and its implications for the global economy. He notes significant movement in the iron ore price following recent supportive policies enacted by the Chinese government and says that if the government can maintain its commitment, there should be limited downside risk to the commodity market. However, he also acknowledges that investor scepticism remains due to past unfulfilled promises. In addressing the issues of insolvency and the subsequent fall of property prices, Gary points out that while many of the top property developers are under financial pressure, the larger problem is the sharp decline in cash flow. He believes that the government's intervention will be crucial in mitigating this issue. He also raises concerns about the reversal of the long-held belief in the continuous growth of home prices, stating that this reversal could drastically affect the Chinese economy. Finally, he offers his insights into the geopolitical landscape following the meeting between President Xi Jinping and President Joe Biden. He suggests that any major shift in US-China relations is unlikely in the short-term, but the recent meetings have limited the potential for further escalation on subjects such as Taiwan. He also mentions the improving relations between China and Australia, and how this could be beneficial for Australian exporters.

- Key topics: China's property sector situation and supportive policies

- Global impact: Iron ore price movements and potential for limited downside risk

- Geopolitical landscape: US-China relations and improving Sino-Australian relations.

Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:

0:00

Let's turn to China now and start things off with a topic that has been talked about for a number of years, but with good reason China's property sector and of course, its impact on the wider global economy. Gary Ng from Natixis joins me now. There was quite a lot of movement in the iron ore price, Gary, on these policy support for China's property sector, but of course, worries about the possible supply disruptions. How are you viewing the overall picture?

0:28

Well, I think the good news that we have here is that over the past few days, we have seen a stronger commitment from the Chinese government on two things. First, it will accelerate this investment through the bond issuance on the central government level to boost infrastructure investment. Second, there's a bit of further relaxation, or at least the commitment towards the support to the property sector. So if we look at this two directions or this two trends, it basically means that China will probably grow a bit quicker, or at least there is a limit to the downside risk to the commodity market, especially on some of the construction materials, iron or steel and etcetera. So aim at this kind of pessimistic world with a very high interest rate. This, this is something that we can be slightly more optimistic from a cyclical point of view. Is it, though, as you've sort of alluded to, a little bit of a boy who cried wolf story as well? Oh, well, indeed. I think one of

1:28

the reasons that investors are not that convinced with all this stimulus is that we've heard a number of times and actually probably more than ten times of, you know, their new stimulus being rolled out in China's property sector. There will be more support from the government. But indeed, if we look at the reality where things has changed or it has only worsened further. Indeed, if you look at property investment, if you look at land sales, think everything related to the property sector has pretty much collapsed. Even though home price is still rather resilient. But from the new home perspective, definitely that will have a spillover effect to us, you know, developers and and etcetera. So this time around, I do think that one of the biggest difference is that all this measures that is announced over the weekend is really about asking banks to support their state sector, giving them more credit, which is quite different from the past in, you know, asking different stakeholders around the economy, like asking investors to buy all these developers

2:28

born in the in the fixed income market. I think this time around it can be different, but we need to still wait and see. Well, when it comes to the overall insolvency issues and the concerns of, I guess, the domino effect of more policy, more property companies, I should say falling over and the likes of what happened to Evergrande and how much of it is more of a liquidity crisis and in terms of just needing a bit more funding.

2:55

Well, indeed. If we look at the top 100 property developers in China, well, of course most of them are basically undergoing very severe pressure in not getting enough cash flow to sustain their business. So think this is definitely for sure. But of course, if we look at whether this is a problem from the solvency level, in some of the examples that we can think of is evergreen, because it has more liability than its assets and its equity prices has collapsed, and therefore it cannot really like, fulfill its

3:28

repayment. Or it's really like a balance sheet crisis. This is really not the norm for most of the developers in China. Basically, if you look at the cash flow saturation, most of them are able to sustain themselves from home sales even though it has collapsed. But the real problem is really about this sharp decline in and cash flow. And I think the government will really need to work harder in mitigating that impact, because otherwise, well, you will simply kill all the profit developers in China. And I don't think this is really, you know, in line with the policy goal. Well, indeed. And it's having quite a flow on effect when it comes to property prices as well, Gary. I mean, we saw China home prices for the most in eight years in October despite this policy support. How concerning is that and how would developers be looking at that?

4:17

Well, for home prices indeed, it is probably reversing a trend that people always believe that home prices will go up forever. And of course, the challenges that China has here is that, first, more than 60% of the household assets in China is actually related to real estate. So of course, on the one hand, if home prices decline, it can maybe improve slightly on affordability. But on the other hand, it will also create a negative spillover towards the wealth effect in terms of whether people think they have money, they have savings to spend. So think this can be an ongoing or increasingly important problem for China to face. And on the other hand, of course, if residents are not that confident about the home price growth in the future, they also less likely to buy homes, right? So this is also like quite negative in terms of, you know, whether China can continue to use real estate as a driver to drive growth in the future. So even though

5:17

we see new sectors like electric vehicles, renewables are growing quite rapidly in China, but they are simply not big enough to offset the drag from real estate, which basically means that China's growth will probably still decelerate in the near term. Okay, Gary, I wanted to ask you a little bit more. We move away from the property sector because, as you say, the golden era seems to be over. But in terms of what we've been seeing with geopolitical relationships, particularly following the President XI and Biden meeting, what sort of positivity do you sense from that, from that gathering and whether or not we're going to move into a different era from what we saw under the Trump presidency?

5:58

Well, I think if we look at the US-China relation is pretty much quite difficult to see a major shift from the current trend. The reason is that I think this strategic competition between China and the US is simply something that is very hard to solve in the short run. And of course, the good news from this meeting and during the APEC conferences that at least I think both parties have limited the downside of further escalation, especially on issues such as Taiwan and etcetera. But on the other hand, whether that will, you know, create like a more relaxed environment in terms of this tech restriction, export bans and etcetera. And I simply think all of these policies will simply continue because the US want to keep it compared to advantage, it want to diversify for China, this is not something that can be solved between one conversation between the two leaders. Okay. And how did you view the meeting between Prime Minister Anthony Albanese

6:57

and also President XI? When we have a lot of concern about the trade tariffs that have been put on Australia, but it does look like a lot of those are being wound back, which is great obviously, for our exporters.

7:11

Well, indeed. If we look at the trade relationship between Australia and China in the past few years, we actually see that of course, there are more sanctions being implemented on Australia on certain products, which probably be some of the kind of the smaller products relative to the other type of products that China really need, and they cannot find it elsewhere. So this basically means that if China needs something, then it will still need to import from somewhere. And if Australia has it and it will still import from Australia if there is no alternative. And of course, this time around, if we see a better relationship between China and Australia, we will probably see more basically a less intense situation on a lot of smaller type of products, which is probably quite important for those sectors, even though they may not be that big for Australia. So definitely it is something that is quite positive, especially on the education services sector. All right. And just a final question on the Hang Seng Index. I mean, it's down about 12% year to

8:10

date. How are you viewing things in Hong Kong. What's the overall kind of consensus of where things move from here?

8:20

Well, indeed. I think the biggest challenge for the investor sentiment in Hong Kong is really about the China policy risk, because investors have simply undergone quite a difficult time in the past two years, and there is simply a more like a PTSD situation to China's related assets in Hong Kong right now that people want to move away, they want to invest in the US, Australia, India or Japan for better return. So think but still are. The good news is that if we are already at the floor in the Hong Kong market, then maybe it cannot fall further. And so if we start to see more policy support from China, it is actually possible that Hong Kong market will actually see a cyclical rebound. But it all depends on when investors believe that it will want to buy into China. Growth story again.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy