Chasing yield? Why total returns matter more than ever
Chasing yield? Why total returns matter more than ever
About this video
Key points:
Rotation towards income-focused strategies amid economic pressures
ASX 200 (ASX:XJO) remains the preferred benchmark for performance comparison
Only a few funds manage to outperform the benchmark on both yield and total return
Diversification within income strategies is critical for long-term investment outcomes
Australian equity income funds are seeing renewed interest as investors shift their focus towards income strategies amid slowing economic growth, elevated cash rates, and persistent cost of living pressures, according to Richard McDougall from Hamilton12. McDougall observes significant capital flows into private credit and high-yield alternatives in recent years, with increased scrutiny now steering investors back toward listed, liquid income strategies. He highlights continued demand for fully franked dividends among Australians and notes that headline yield alone does not guarantee better total returns.
McDougall analyses Morningstar data for Australian equity income funds up to 30 September, noting approximately $17 billion invested in higher-yielding strategies. Using the ASX 200 (ASX:XJO) as a practical benchmark, he finds only a small group of funds—about five, including one feeder ETF—delivering higher yield and higher total returns than the benchmark, amounting to roughly $8 billion in funds under management. In contrast, a larger portion, about $9 billion, sits in funds underperforming the benchmark on total returns, with $1.3 billion producing both lower yield and lower return.
He urges investors to prioritise total return over headline yield and consider diversified strategies rather than concentrated ones, as diversification typically supports both higher yield and sustainable growth.