Sign inJoin free

Watch / Tech & Telco

Can Vodafone challenge Alibaba as 2024’s best value investment?

27 Mar 20247:48

Can Vodafone challenge Alibaba as 2024’s best value investment?

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Tim Davies from Carrara Capital discussed investment opportunities with Vodafone. After a previous endorsement of Alibaba (9988), Tim now suggests that there is potential for a stellar investment with the telecommunications company this year. He highlights Vodafone's (VOD) considerable assets, including $69 billion of debt and payables and the reported $89 billion on the asset side, making its enterprise value -£2 billion. Tim is particularly interested in Vodafone's global subscriber base of 300 million and forecasts for £13 billion EBITDA for the current year.

A big plus for Vodafone, according to Tim, is the new CEO who joined in April 2023 having a clear mandate to improve core operations, chiefly in Germany and the UK, whilst also executing numerous non-core asset sales. Tim discussed Vodafone's decision to exit small markets where they are a minor player and highly competitive markets where they can't gain ground. An additional sweetener Tim mentions is the proposed redistribution of cash to shareholders. After the recent sale to Swisscom (SCMN), Vodafone announced a 50% cut on dividends and a share buyback of £3.5 billion, approximately 19% of the stock.

Tim says he believes that Vodafone's current status makes it a prime target for private equity firms. The telecommunication company's substantial range of listed assets, potential growth markets and current low valuation price, set Vodafone up as a potential acquisition. Looming over this is the possibility of a merger with Three UK, a move that has caused some regulatory hesitance. Despite this hurdle, Tim considers the company to be undervalued and maintains that the catalysts far outweigh this issue.

Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:

0:00

Let's get into some investing themes for 2020 for my next guest, Tim Davies from Carrara Capital. When he joined us a couple of weeks ago, Tim said that Alibaba could be the best investment of the year from a value perspective. Now, he says there's another stock that can challenge that. Market's always moving. What is it, Tim? Vodafone. Right. Yes. Very interesting. Um, you know, I think it's a name that's been completely forgotten. Yeah. Um, you know, I remember back in 2000 when they paid £180 billion for the management joint venture, and its market cap today is just £18 billion. So it's sort of disappeared off the radar. And why do you think it's coming back then? So I think I think it's we look at it in four ways. You know, to think about Vodafone. First of all, if we look at its balance sheet, um, it has about $69 billion pounds or, excuse me, of debt and, um, payables. If we look at the asset side, uh, so the liability side is 69 billion, the asset side about 89 billion. So if we go through those, it's got about

1:00

24 billion of cash. Um, quite uniquely, it's got about $20 billion of listed assets around the world that range from transmission towers, phone companies in India. Um, it owns 25% of TPG in Australia. So it's got a really unique pool of assets that are listed, a lot of assets in Africa as well. Um, on top of that, it, uh, it just sold a couple of businesses. So it sold its Italian and its Spanish operations and picked up about £11 billion for that. And finally it has about £32 billion of infrastructure. So when we we add all those numbers together, we subtract it from the market cap. We get an enterprise value of -£2 billion. So um, effectively you can pick it up for free relative to its asset base. Um, you touched on India there. I mean, their market base is huge. I believe Vodafone is very, very big in India. And that's a lot of subscribers, a lot of customers. What is this, a sort of subscriber base globally then. So it has

1:59

300 million subscribers globally. Right. Um, it's forecast to do about £13 billion of EBITDA this year. So as I touched on its negative EV with £13 billion of EBITDA. So, um, it's it's quite unique. I think what's, what's changing around Vodafone is a new CEO who joined in April 2023 with a really clear mandate from the board to improve its core operations, particularly in Germany and in the UK. Uh, but also to do a lot of non-core asset sales, which would be those Spanish and Italian assets. So it's looking around at its markets that it's a small player in highly competitive markets and saying, look, we're wasting our time being in here. We can't get to scale with a lot of investment required to sort of keep going. So, um, as well as that, um, there's, there's a real focus of returning cash to shareholders. So when they announced the

2:59

sale last week to Swisscom, the Italian asset, um, you know, Vodafone has been paying about a 10 or 11% dividend. So the CEO cut the dividend in half, but announced a share buyback of £3.5 billion. Now that's 19% of the stock. So that'll be on market. So we think that's a huge catalyst to get the stock moving. Uh on top of that, the largest shareholder is a subsidiary of the United Arab Emirates government that owns 15%. Yeah. And so it's it's just taking a board seat. Um, and it's got approval from the UK and is awaiting approval from the German government as well, uh, to come onto market and buy 10% more stocks. So potentially we've got 30% of stock up for grabs in a company. As I touched on, that's extremely undervalued. So there's a real push by management to get this share price moving. Um, by by consolidating the business, making it leaner. Um, and you know, we

3:59

think it's we think it's probably really attractive for a private equity play. I was about to say, what is the likelihood that it then becomes an acquisition or a very potential move by a private equity firm? Well, we think so. Right. Like there's not a lot of assets that sit around like this. If these telecommunications are such a core part of our life and, um, you know, I think it's a lot easier than it sounds, I think for a private equity firm, given that Vodafone's, you know, a big chunk of its asset base is listed. Um, so it's a matter of potentially it may want to hold those assets, the Indian assets, it may want to, you know, hang on to its African assets, which is clearly going to be a really long term growth market for it.

4:39

Um, the price would be interesting. You know, at £0.68 today, it's, it's selling assets at six times EV EBITDA at the moment. So you know, that would put a sale price above £2. I think if anyone was serious about wanting to take a look at Vodafone, you know, this would be a classic Macquarie Bank, right. If you go back 5 or 10. Years. And the quarterback teams I'm sure would be would love an asset like this to sort of break break it apart and release that value for its shareholders. So we we would expect that there are a lot of private equity firms we would think are probably having a good look at it at the moment. Um, the one negative is that, uh, they're trying to merge with three UK. So the UK market has for operators. There's been a lot of mergers over the last five years. Um, the regulator came out last week and has pushed it to level two. So it's concerned about reducing competition in the market. So that's probably the one negative to hold it back. But but relative to the valuation and

5:39

that 30% share buyback that we see coming through potentially we think the catalysts far outweigh that that issue. Let's talk a little bit more about the share buyback. Because you mentioned the CEO very much um, trying to streamline the company. What sort of return can shareholders expect? What's the share buyback involve? And I guess what kind of further capital or dividends are shareholders expecting to. So, you know, they announced to cut the dividend in half. So their view is look we think we'll get realized better value for shareholders by buying those shares back then returning you know the extra 5% dividends. So um, if we look at the valuation side of it today, you know, I looked across the top five mobile companies and said, look, what are they trading at on, um, and so it would put Vodafone at about £1.75 if we look at the average multiples. So about 160% upside is, is just to get to that average multiple. Um, it's as I said, it's selling its businesses at six times, which would

6:39

push it over £250 to £3. So potentially this is a golden egg sitting there that I think, you know, investors, um, you know, they could be really attracted to it. So is it better than Alibaba or just different. It's just different. So you still you still love Alibaba as well. Yeah. Look you know I think if we touch on China quickly I think we've had a couple of results out over the last week. I think uh Tencent's results looked really, really good. I think particularly Q4, uh, a lot of talk about the benefits of AI, particularly in advertising and tailoring advertising to consumers by, you know, bringing a lot more customers, um, as in corporate customers who are attracted to their AI. You know, our language learning models, to be able to actually target specific consumers with what they're looking for. Um, as well as that, we had BYD last night that I think, um, slight disappointment, but but really strong

7:38

results, uh, and made sure Meituan crushed it. They had absolutely fantastic results on Friday night. Uh, EBITDA was up 720% year on year.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy