Can earnings surprises be predicted?
About this video
Key points:
The predictability of earnings surprises and the contributing factors
The role of analyst forecasts in predicting surprises
The influence of a company's size and earnings yield on earnings surprises
Jason Hall of Hamilton12 provides insight into the predictability of earnings surprises from companies, indicating it's not a foolproof process but certain trends can be identified. Drawing from analysis of Australian companies over the past 36 years, Jason points out that certain degrees of earnings surprises can be predicted. He likens this predictability to underestimations of quotes in industries such as construction.
Detailing the key factors of this process, Jason remarks that recent upgrades and downgrades can give a clear signal on the potential for earnings surprises. The slower updates from analysts after a recent update can create misconceptions in consensus numbers. More importantly, disagreement amongst analysts' forecasts increases the chances of a downside surprise. He further mentions that larger companies are more likely to surprise on the upside. They manage expectations well and have fewer incentives to unduly influence their share price.
Finally, Jason conveys the influence of earnings yield on the likelihood of earning surprises. Companies with higher earnings yield or lower price-to-earnings ratio against analyst's forecasts are more likely to bring about a downside surprise. Thus, comparing companies within the same industry can also play a key role in predicting potential earnings surprises. To conclude, although not foolproof, Jason suggests these elements can enhance the predictability of earnings surprises to some extent.