Can China revive consumer confidence?
About this video
Tano Pelosi from Antares Capital notes the Chinese economy is taking a piecemeal approach to stimulus without major fiscal changes. He highlights the weak consumer sector amid a debt deflationary spiral and structural imbalances, particularly in the property sector.
Tano mentions China's struggle to transition from manufacturing to a services-led economy, drawing parallels with Japan's past economic stagnation. He observes rising household debt and a cautious approach to policy, with potential geopolitical concerns affecting trade and commodity prices.
Turning to the US, Tano discusses the Federal Reserve's efforts to maintain a neutral rate, suggesting a potential fed funds rate of 2.5-3.5%. He sees their approach as supportive for risk assets despite inflation risks, especially concerning rising oil prices and late-cycle economic conditions in the US.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
So let's, uh, just check out what we should be watching on at a macro level. Tanner Pelosi joining us from Ontario's capital territory. Good to catch up with you again. Well, let's start with China. Uh, we're just talking about there's so much expectation built into what we're going to hear in terms of further stimulatory measures. Um, how how would you sum up what we've got already from China?
0:23
Morning, Andrea. I mean, I guess the first thing to say is the markets have been highly conditioned to expect sort of stock and all kind of big Bang policy stimulus. And, you know, we're not getting that at the moment. Um, we are getting what looks like sort of a piecemeal approach without major, major fiscal stimulus. Certainly the monetary stimulus we saw a few weeks back, uh, was important. And I think, uh, you know, it's certainly he's moving in the right direction, but we haven't seen anything as yet that it was really going to move the dial. Um, and Particularly what I'm referring to. There is something that really will help re stimulate the household sector, the consumer, particularly because, um, ostensibly consumption is very weak at the moment. Um, in fact, you could say that they're in the throes of a sort of a debt deflationary spiral. I mean, I don't want overstated, but, um, certainly deflation is coming through and
1:22
consumption is very, very soft.
1:26
So, um, well, I just mentioned the Goldman Sachs, um, anticipating that it is going to hit its 5% target. I mean, it tends to be I don't know how accurate it is anyway, isn't it really the forecasts we get from China. But but absolutely it is a dark art. Yeah. When we're talking about, uh, this particular economy, I think one of the things we know is that they and, you know, to their credit, they try to address some of these structural imbalances, some of the structural weaknesses within the economy, particularly around the property sector. And we also knew that the property sector accounted for a very large component of GDP in growth, just generally growth. So what we've seen since those measures they took somewhat two years ago now is that house prices have in many, particularly second tier cities have fallen. And whilst that has been the backdrop, it's very hard to
2:25
reinvigorate spending household spending. So this is really the crux of the problem. I mean, we could we could probably, uh, further extend this out and say there are some structural issues also going on in in the background and, you know, ageing demographics and, um, an economy that is not got a real good balance of growth drivers and arguably also some ideological opposition from the government towards the types of stimulus packages we've seen from the West, you know, essentially cash drops or cheques being sent out to households. They've been really refraining from doing that, doing that. And the markets have been really looking for that. That's essentially large fiscal transfers to the household sector. So that's the first and first. Firstly, I would say that that that is what's missing from all these policy measures. And then the second thing is really addressing this issue around house prices. So, you know,
3:25
they've stopped short of going full QE and trying to protect the housing sector and look for it's very unlikely we're going to see that type of policy response that the typical response you would see from, say, a fed or even an RBI for that matter, where you're buying those sort of assets, where you're trying to prop up because you're trying to avoid a deflationary spiral. But that's that's kind of the backdrop they're in. It's a very difficult situation. Uh, and all the, all the while, you know, in the background again, you've got rising private household debt. Household debt levels are now becoming quite, quite, um,
4:05
uh, you know, quite, quite a problem and really handicapping the economy from, uh, really taking advantage of some of these measures. The government's bringing to the fore, uh, in terms of more supply of finance, um, you know, essentially allowing the banks to free up capital to the private sector. But the problem is the demand side, and you can't get consumers to borrow if there's a lack of confidence.
4:32
Is this all part of the difficulty, I guess, the Chinese economy is going through in terms of transitioning from a manufacturing to a services economy?
4:42
Well, I think you've hit the nail on the head right there. So and this is many of the same issues Japan confronted, you know, as it moved from the 80s into the 90s. And of course, that didn't work out too well for them. We saw them essentially, essentially in a secular stagnation for the next 20 years, 20, 25, 30 years almost, and only really now emerging in that economy from from that. And, you know, they've managed to reflate the economy. So, uh, and whilst we're on Japan, that's one of the reasons why they're perhaps very cautious in the way they're normalizing rates. So China perhaps is in the throes or at least that the early stages of that. I mean, clearly the age demographic issue and the one child policy, uh, whilst, you know, that's sort of in the rear view, they have managed to rekindle that, uh, that area and essentially do what we did back in 2006 seven, you know, with, uh,
5:42
providing stimulus for families to have more kids. So they have managed to do that. And the other broader problem here is that they are essentially producing too much for what they consume at a time when there are, you know, in the crosshairs, there's geopolitics, there's the potential trade wars, and, you know, maybe a magnification of that going forward. And so you've got, uh, weak imports coming through for China, which is, uh, really a problem for many, many trading partners. On the flip side, um, because because you don't get that re channeling of money back into the global economy. And you can see that in commodity prices, particularly what's happened to iron ore prices most recently. So, uh, also on that score, you can see what's going on in certain, uh, industrial, um, very strong industrial
6:42
economies in Europe, um, in terms of their exports to China. So it's it's really, you know, you've got this sort of spillover effect coming from a weak consumer. But all the while you've got this. What is really the impetus of the problem is that not only are there weak sort of credit impulse drivers coming through, but you've got a structural change going on in the backdrop that is really just trying to balance out growth away from investment and exports into more like a US or first world economy, where you have a lot more household consumption as a proportion of total GDP. Speaking of the US turn, I just before I let you go, um, how would you view where that economy is tracking the moment? Do you feel as though the fed has actually managed to walk that fine line?
7:36
Yes, Andrew. I think they're doing a great job here. And ostensibly, I think the the idea that they try to get back to neutral is broadly right. We can debate where that neutral fed funds rate is. I think where I kind of lean and have lent on, uh, in terms of my bias has been that the markets were pricing in something like a one stage, 225 points of cuts. I thought there was perhaps a little bit too much and still perhaps argue that the risks are probably less than more. So you get to, you know, I guess the range of outcomes here over the next 12 to 18 months is you get to a fed funds rate of, say, two and a half to three and a half. And, you know, my personal view is probably closer to three and a half than two and a half. But broadly the markets have got right. I think it's supportive for risk assets, equities, credit markets, because you've got a fed here that is really endeavoring to bring off a soft landing,
8:36
uh, at a time when inflation is also moderating. Now the clearly there are a couple key risks on the horizon here. One of them is that you are you continue to get this nice sort of, uh, impulse on inflation gravitating towards that core target of 2%. It's currently around 2.6. So there are some risks around that, particularly as we move into the late cycle of this, uh, of, of this US economy, uh, through 2025. And also I'm also watching what's happening in terms of inflation expectations, particularly with, uh, the geopolitics and, you know, rising oil prices that could also throw a spanner in the works where it prevents the fed taking the cash rate down as much as what the markets imply. So there are a couple of risks on the horizon, but for now certainly supportive I think certainly to risk assets, but also over the medium term to the bond market as we try to find out where that sort of equilibrium
9:36
point is. Uh, and arguably that could be a little bit higher than what the Fed's arguing at around 3%.