Are tech stocks positioned to do well again?
Are tech stocks positioned to do well again?
About this video
Shaun Ler from Morningstar delves into the outlook for Australia's listed wealth management sector and specifically shares his thoughts on various stocks. Shaun explains that asset and wealth management stocks remain popular financial entities due to their prospective dividends and growth. Yet, these companies are susceptible to fluctuations in interest rates, which can affect their anticipated profits and margins. He notes that dividends and earnings are likely to improve, even if interest rates decrease. However, these businesses must compete with passive bonds and super funds, which may require fee reductions.
In terms of specific stocks, Shaun cites Pinnacle and Challenger as likely candidates for a swift recovery of inflows and earnings. Conversely, he mentions that firms such as Magellan and Platinum might encounter more significant fee and margin compression due to subpar performance and high fees. The wealth management sector remains varied, with businesses such as Net Wealth and Top 24 seeing robust growth, despite being considered expensive.
In the future, Shaun discussed the Australian listed tech sector to face further pressure if interest rates remain high for an extended period. Despite this, he mentions companies like Phoenix (FCL) and Tyro Payments as potentially resilient businesses, thanks to their enhanced offerings and advantageous market positions. Lastly, he also names Insignia Financial as another undervalued entity, with scope for future earnings stabilisation.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Let's get stock specifics though, and really tap into a theme. And that is the listed wealth management sector and outlook for stocks in this sector in particular. Shaun Ler from Morningstar joins me now. Shaun, hi. Welcome to the program. Good morning to you. Um, okay. So just lay like, give us the lay of the land here. What are we talking about?
0:23
Well. Good morning. Thanks for having me. Um, I guess, uh, we are talking about welfare and asset management companies to start with. Um, look, you know, for those who are not too familiar yet, the asset managers and the wealth managers, uh, the stocks in this country are arguably the most popular financial companies, right after the banks and the insurance companies, because some of them provide good dividends, some of them have high growth. Um, but, you know, you know, funny that you've mentioned interest rates about, you know, less than two minutes ago. So for the asset managers, you know, this is a cohort that's highly, uh, sensitive to interest rates. Now consensus is saying that we are past peak interest rates globally excluding Australia. So in general these asset managers are seeing flows improve. Now we continue to expect the flows and earnings for these asset managers and wealth managers to improve. But even if rates and rates are eventually cut and the flows improve, we still expect them to earn, uh, lower margins. Uh, then before then the past, because, you
1:23
know, these companies still need to compete with the rise of passive bonds or super funds in the country, which means that they still need to lower fees, um, spend money on distribution with cost inflation. And of course, you know, within the cohort, different asset managers, uh, have different fortunes, right? You know, the better performing ones, um, and the more diversified ones like pinnacle Challenger, you know, we think that they are likely to have a faster recovery, uh, inflows and earnings, um, on, on in other hand, you get um, some companies like Magellan and Platinum, you know, with somewhat subpar performance and higher fees, these companies will likely see a larger fee compression and margin compression, in our view. Um, if we look at the wealth managers, you know, it continues to be a mixed bag. Um, you know, the better quality ones, um, like top 24 net worth, very strong growth, but very expensive in our view. Um, but the cheap ones like IWM or Insignia Financial are more
2:23
challenged. Uh, for net wealth and top 24. Um, there's a tendency for them to start copying each other, launch lower cost products. And we think that these business models are commodity um for the incumbents in Signal Financial or AMP. You know, the story has always been the same for quite some time. You know, it's about cost out, um, improving flows into their core platforms and persisting outflows from their legacy products. All right. So, um, just to reiterate, you see challenger in a pretty strong position. Where else in the asset managers.
2:57
Well when it comes to the asset manager, when it comes to set managers, we tend to see more competitive advantage and more, I guess, ability to attract flows, uh, for companies that are more diversified. So I've talked to I've talked about challenger, um, because firstly they have a large annuities business, but they also own Fidelity Partners, uh, which is a multi boutique which is similar to Pinnacle Investment Management. Uh, both both these business models are multi boutiques that possess, you know, a diversified array of funds between, you know, changes between different asset classes, um, and fund managers. So that sort of helps smoothing out the volatility. And that sort of helps them attract flows uh, throughout market conditions. But obviously you need to be you need to be a strong performing. And the good thing is that their boutiques have tended to perform quite well.
3:45
Okay. Interesting. So. Pinnacle and challenger on the list there. When we look further afield or when you're looking further afield at given what we've talked about this interest rate backdrop, Sean, what do you expect to happen to the Australian listed tech sector if rates do remain higher for longer?
4:09
Well,
4:10
that's a that's a good question. Uh, look, for the most of 2022 and 2023, the tech companies have responded to investor demands for profitability, uh, by reducing costs, uh, exiting non-core businesses and increasing prices. Um, you know, as of now, many tech companies have shown that they can grow profits and the prices have somewhat recovered. But that said, you know, not all tech companies are created equal. If you think about the firms that do well, they tend to be those that play a more mission critical role. For example, uh, logistics or enterprise software like, you know, Y Stan, LTM or technology one. Um, but in the financial sector, uh, the tech stocks that I cover tend to be credit providers that use technology, uh, some payment processors and also enterprise software. So the credit providers that I cover are like zip and hum and some processors like EML payments, you know, in our opinion they are likely to remain focused in their core businesses. They are not in a position to reinvest heavily for
5:10
growth yet. Uh, that's because they remain as small players that are behind large competitors. Uh, their earnings are not not yet stable, uh, at risk of further deterioration. The headwinds are still there. Some of them need to do with higher funding costs. Some of them still have lots of work to do to trim their cost base. Um, that said, you know, there are some companies which are better in this list. Uh, one company that I've talked about multiple times in the past, uh, is Phoenix. So the stock code is FCL. Um, and to some extent, uh, another company in this space would be uh, Tyro Payments. So to start with Phoenix, you know, it has strong customers, which of course, uh, strong product utility, significant product development spend, uh, that has barriers to entry. Now, both Phoenix and Tyro have relatively more, uh, differentiated offerings that allow them to take market share and improve their earnings from current levels as compared to the other, um, more commoditized business models that I've talked about. Um, and Finney is just to be clear for our viewers is
6:09
FCL. So you might want to take a look and do a little bit of your own research on that. So again,
6:17
um, if we could sum it up, given what we know about the higher for longer narrative that has taken hold here in Australia, what are some of what are some of your best ideas in terms of your coverage or have we named them?
6:31
Well, that's a good question. So I guess, um, I guess I wouldn't get too caught up with, you know, where we are, the interest rates and up and down, etc.. Um, you know, what we what we tend to look over here is, you know, what stocks are, you know, undervalued. What stocks are overvalued. At the end of the day, the returns you get depend on the price that you pay. So, you know, I've talked about fairness in it being a cheap uh cheap stock. Um, another company in that list would be Insignia Financial, which is both uh, now for both for Insignia Financial. So I'm referring to the old name. But the, you know, for insignia the market is somewhat pricing in outflows to continue. Um, and cost to keep increasing resulting in a very long earnings decline. Um, in our view, that's quite pessimistic. And we think that the company can stabilize its earnings moving forward. Um, the core expense platform has been consistently improvised and have comparable features of their competitors. The fee margins for their platforms and their funds are competitive, meaning that, you know, the fee compression should be less intense and
7:31
hopefully flow should improve. Um, the advisor losses are slowing down and the remaining advisors are more productive. And, you know, another important thing is that is cost, sales and business simplification are ongoing and have also reduced a lot of costs. So I would say, you know, it's true of our biggest undervalued ideas in the diversified financials list right now, um, is Venus, uh, tyro payments that I've talked as I've talked about and and insignia Financial.