Are investment managers performing on skill or luck?
About this video
Richard McDougall from Hamilton 12 joins to discuss the S&P Dow Jones Industries Australia Persistence Scorecard for the year-end 22. The Persistence Scorecard is a separate report which compares the consistency of performance of active managers relative to their peers over time and demonstrates whether a manager performs on skill or luck. The report reveals that performance lags worsen as time passes, making it harder to identify active managers likely to earn above-median performance in the future if they have earned it previously.
Investors need to consider whether the investment manager's disclosed process appears consistent with the results, which will help understand whether their success is based on skill or luck. Although empirical data supports that most active managers should underperform most of the time, some active managers succeed due to their genuine skills. Investors should differentiate and consider the strategy of the active manager and decide whether their success is based on skill rather than luck.