Are active ETFS the death or the future of the Aussie market?
Are active ETFS the death or the future of the Aussie market?
About this video
Key insights:
Significant shift seen in Australia's ETF landscape with the rise of active ETFs
Mutual funds being converted into ETFs among fund managers to access different market segments
Bitcoin ETFs as an indicator to the legitimacy of the asset class
Kanish Chugh, an independent market commentator,says that the rise of active ETFs signifies a shift in Australia's investment landscape, attracting big players such as JPMorgan and Macquarie into this space. He says that Australia is at the forefront of ETF innovation, with active fund managers using ETFs to reach new client markets. Kanish reveals that the widespread popularity of ETFs, coupled with the clear regulations, are making ETFs more accessible for investors.
Regarding the entrance of traditional players into the ETF space, Kanish says that there is a trend for mutual funds to be converted into ETFs. He cites Pimco as an example, which plans to convert one of its mutual funds directly into an ETF. This strategy allows fund managers to access different market segments, making it more appealing for private wealth, stockbrokers, and direct retail investors. He predicts a growing reliance on ETFs as more advisors become comfortable with their use.
Kanish then discussed the recent interest in Bitcoin ETFs, especially by retail investors in the US. He believes that the SEC's allowance for investment in Bitcoin legitimises the asset class, attracting institutional investors. He also mentions the possibility of an Ethereum ETF launch later this year. He then addresses the concern about ETF closures, assuring that investor assets are safe with independent custodians, and the closures are part of the market maturing. Kanish views this development as indicative of the future of the Australian ETF industry.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Let's turn to ETFs. Now. Is the rise of active ETFs a game changer or the end for traditional exchange traded funds to discuss what's luring big players like JPMorgan and Macquarie into this space. And if we're witnessing a global shift. Kanish Chugh, Independent market commentator, joins me up on the desk. Good to see you. Kanish. Um, so are we seeing a bit of a shift when you start to see a lot more of these industries in play? Definitely. We are. So in Australia, we've always been one of those unique markets. We're at the forefront of a lot of ETF innovation. And a number of years ago, Magellan was actually the first active player to launch an exchange created managed fund. Essentially it's a it's an active fund in a ETF listed vehicle. So when we scale it back ETFs are traditionally been passive S&P 500, ASX 200 gold, etc.. But active fund managers are utilizing the vehicle of it being listed to try and tap into new client markets. It actually opens up a lot more doors, and it makes it much more accessible for investors to access. So it's funny,
0:59
Australia's started to see a lot of new active players into the market. So last year we saw JP Morgan dimensional, which is one of the largest US fund managers. Macquarie here locally. Um you've also got but in the US you're actually seeing this really big push. And in Europe they're actually stating that about nine out of ten active fund managers, about 92% out of a recent survey by Blackwater, will launch an ETF vehicle in some way, shape or form. So what is driving them? What is attracting them to launching these funds? Is it the old supply and demand? Yeah, I think it's a combination. So what we've seen definitely from an ETF industry around the world, Australia, US in particular is a lot more investment flows. So the traditional fund vehicle has its limitations. You could call that. So in Australia, for example, a traditional fund vehicle may limit the types of clients that could access that particular exposure. So whether it be sMSf clients that use your CommSec very well, you know, attuned to investing in listed shares,
1:59
may not look at a listed fund. And what we've seen is this popularity around ETFs. So that's one definite. The other side is we're actually seeing Pimco for example, is actually going to convert one of their mutual funds directly into an ETF. So I think that's the next big adoption. What we've seen in Australia is a lot of fund managers active fund managers, and rightly so. Go we've got an active fund, and we're going to now list a version of that in an ETF form. And it's now the regulations around it are quite clear and it's become a lot easier for them to do so here in Australia. But now we actually I personally believe we may see active fund managers even leapfrog that traditional fund structure set up in some times to go direct into an ETF form. Now you access different market segments. So if you have a mutual fund, you traditionally can go direct. But the hurdles are quite high. The minimum investment for example. And you have to go through a financial planner, whereas the listed vehicle you generally can open it up into the private wealth, the stockbrokers, you know, your showroom partners, order minutes, etc. but
2:59
also then you look at your direct retail as well for certain strategies. They may look to certain companies anyway, but it requires a lot of money as well in terms of marketing and building up a brand in that space, what sort of demand are we seeing in terms of, I mean, you mentioned in stores there as well, but if you look at the Bitcoin ETFs, just the demand in that has just really exploded. And that just kind of seems that there's a lot of retail people getting in as well. So yes and no. So in the US definitely it's been a lot more retail. Um, I've been listening to quite a few podcasts actually around this Bitcoin ETF in the US, and I was actually part of the team locally to launch the first Bitcoin ETF here in Australia. So quite well there's a long regulatory, um, sort of many hurdles to have gotten through. Um, here in Australia took nearly, you know, 5 to 6 years over in the US. It's sort of sitting at that space an SEC are now looking at the Ethereum product, what the Bitcoin ETF has done. And you're seeing Bitcoin prices sort of hit record highs more recently is it's legitimize an asset class
3:58
that some investors would have said no I'm not going to look at it. And as soon as you have the SEC comes out and says whilst is high risk associated with this asset class, we allow the structure so they allow investment in a regulated form. Then you have companies like fidelity, Blackrock, um, these companies are well institutionalized, highly regulated companies. They're not going to sit there and back something that they personally believe made clothes in the next 3 to 6 months. So they've done their due diligence and they've launched into these funds. So you've started to legitimize what is essentially a deregulated asset class. And so you have some investors that probably were sitting on the sideline. They don't want to open up the crypto account. They don't want to have that. You have those diehard crypto enthusiasts. It's very easy to open up a crypto account. There are risks with that. We all know, you know, we've seen some of those exchanges fall over and there's some security risks. But so if those that have wanted to invest in crypto, they've already done so. The Bitcoin ETFs are for those retail investors that have sat on that sideline
4:58
unsure about. Do I want to open up with this exchange or that exchange? Do I am scared of my, you know, keeping my keychain and all of those sorts of things? So the security aspect, they buy into a regulated structure and a product that's been, you know, well, you know, due diligence has been done on it. Um, and I think we'll also start to see, you know, the Ethereum ETF start to come through towards the back end of this year as well. Let's talk about fund managers converting some of these mutual funds into ETFs as well. And whether that can be sort of an identical strategy that people use in in what context. Just in terms of converting this mutual fund into an ETF. So yeah, so I think what they've done is so Pimco is a good example, um, where they've decided so they already have a mutual fund and an identical ETF running side by side. What they've what they're looking to do actually they're going to look to convert one of their mutual funds. It's one of their mortgage backed security funds into an ETF. Now that could be for a variety of reasons. But I think the key part there is when you think about an ETF
5:58
here in Australia, majority of inflows is actually through the advisor community. So it's through your private wealth advisors, your financial advisors, your stockbrokers, the retail investors are picking up in terms of interest and inflows into ETFs. But it's still very much an advice driven investment product. So as more advisors around the world start to become comfortable with the use of ETFs in portfolios, and that's been a big hurdle. You know, we've had certain regulations so far, etc.. The royal commissions here bringing down the fees. You start to see changes in advice, behavior and advisors have started to use more ETFs and portfolios than they traditionally did. So before I remember talking to a lot of advisors that would be like, I don't know what an ETF is. I'm concerned about, you know, liquidity, etc. they now understand liquidity and they're now comparing ETFs to each other. So now fund managers such as the active institutional fund managers are going, okay, well this is an era we don't. We can have an ETF. And financial planners which were traditionally our main client segment are going to use them as well. So we're not sort of
6:57
taking out a complete client segment. So that's what you're starting to see. It's your professional investors, your retail investors. And even you have some super funds. And institutions will use certain listed products where required, especially for tactical allocations and for short term allocations, because ETFs, you've got a lot more. And should we be concerned about ETF closures which have changed globally. Yeah. So in Australia we only have just around 340 ETFs listed. You generally haven't seen many closures. We definitely have seen some closures in the market here. And that's part of a maturing market. But in the US for example there's been 65 ETFs closed year to date. The same period for last year was 33. So definitely a pickup. But in 2023 there was 246 closures. But then let's compare that to number of openings. And there were 529 new ETFs listed in the US. So I think it's a factor of ETFs opening into the market, the market maturing, the industry maturing. But I think people need to be aware what happens.
7:57
And in Australia I can tell you having gone through that process of closing some ETFs is that the investors are safe. You know, they're assets that sit within that structure are safe. They sit with a separate independent custodians. And what will happen is either they can trade out of the fund before the closing date, or the funds will get returned to them via their registry. So there is no issue with that aspect, but it is more of a hassle that investors have to face. But we generally see ETFs being around for at least 3 to 5 years because you want when launching an ETF, it's very costly and you want to have that product run through different, you know, cycles within the market. And you need to ensure that that product is also being backed commercially as well. So you generally see sort of a five year life on ETFs before. And generally, you know, majority of the ETFs that were closed in the US, there was sub20 million of assets. So that just shows you they're not they're not economical to run.