Sign inJoin free

Watch / Economy

APRA's "gutsy" move

16 Sept 20248:32

APRA's "gutsy" move

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Charlie Callan from BondAdviser describes APRA’s decision to eliminate AT1 hybrids for banks as a bold move that surprises the market. APRA aims to make the Australian banking system safer by simplifying capital frameworks. However, the change may complicate lives for the next eight years and reduce income options for investors.

Smaller banks are expected to face more challenges in attracting funding due to limited access to the international debt capital markets. Insurers, on the other hand, benefit as there are no proposed changes for their capital requirements. This decrease in the market size could revive the listed bond market, benefiting corporate and income funds.

The proposal is not yet in effect but is likely to become effective from January 2027. The new rules could pose significant challenges to banks and investors accustomed to the benefits of AT1 hybrids.

Full unedited transcript:

0:00

A gutsy document that tears up the playbook on bank regulatory capital funding. That's how Charlie Callan from Bond Advisor has described Apra's decision to axe 81 hybrids for banks. He joins us now to explain. Charlie, thanks for joining us again from Bond Advisor. All right. So what have. Why are APRA going down this path. What's triggered it.

0:26

G'day, Andrew. Good to see you again. Look, um, it's caught everyone a bit off guard, I would say here in terms of what APRA is done. And and to answer your first question as to why they've done this. The simple answer that they give is they want to make the Australian banking system safer. And what that really means is protecting depositors. Um, you know, whether or not that actually does this, um, is is, I would say a little bit, uh, uncertain in the market at the moment. There's a few things being processed by everyone here but you. You're right They've torn up the rulebook. Uh, APA actually wants to take a different path to global regulators. And bizarrely, it even goes against some of its own ball three standards that it has sought itself to uphold. So, in short, what does it mean? Well, I think plenty of your viewers would know what H1 hybrids are. Uh, and for Australian banks, that market will cease to exist if these proposed changes go through. Uh, for insurers, it's going to stick around. But you're talking about a

1:26

market that's going to dramatically shrink off the back of this. And, um, ultimately, you know, why is that happening? How is this happening? Well, APRA wants to get rid of, uh, AT1 capital altogether, which is particularly interesting because, um,

1:42

um, no other regulator has sought to do this globally. Um, a couple of kind of hinted at possibly doing it, but but APRA is very much the first mover here. So he wants to simple simplify the capital framework for banks, uh, by just issuing tier two capital and just issuing common equity. Um, but in fact, it's, you know, going to make everyone's lives a lot more complicated, I think, for possibly the next eight years. And, you know, off the back of this, it's going to be a bit of a gold rush. There is some 40 plus billion dollars worth of AT1 hybrids in our local market. The big five make up circa 38 billion of that. And investors are going to need other forms of income. Um, and, you know, there's plenty of investors that that love the franked income that you get on a hybrid. They're not going to be able to get that, um, to the same extent. Um, and so we think there's going to be a raft of kind of new and innovative income products off the back of this to meet this demand. But another really important point is some people have been talking about an

2:42

ASX two market returning. Um, we don't think that's going to occur if you if you read into the detail of what APRA has been talking about, they're very concerned about providing AT1 hybrids or tier two bonds to the retail market. And the reason why is because of the litigation risk of mis selling. And it's the contagion risk that it introduces to the system. So that to come back to your question of why that actually taken a lot of the analysis that's been done by the Bank of International Settlements in Spain in their banking crisis in 2008 to 2014. And what happened with Credit Suisse and some of the American banks are more recently.

3:25

So who then is likely to lose out as a result of the move?

3:31

Yeah. The obvious. The obvious loser for us is the regional and smaller banks from a funding diversification perspective. Um, these these banks as it is, struggle to attract big order books in tier two subordinated bonds. And you know, from what we understand, there's really only just a couple more than a handful of local investors that make up the institutional bed of of this part of the market. Um, so those institutional players here, you know, get more power over these smaller banks in terms of the pricing that they're going to set. And what that means is, ultimately, these smaller banks are going to have to pay away even more to to get the attention of those that are willing to fund their subordinated capital. Making this worse for those banks is they don't have great access to the international debt capital markets. You know, our big four and big five banks can, you know, turn to the global capital markets overnight and raise billions of dollars if they would like. That is not the case for our smaller banks. And so, you know, APRA was talking

4:31

about how this will, uh, you know, be beneficial for those banks. We actually think it's the opposite. We think it's going to be worse, uh, quite frankly. And we wouldn't be surprised to, to, um, understand that bank these smaller bank treasurers have been ruing the day since this report came out. Franklin.

4:48

Um, the other obvious losers that I spoke about before is, you know, investors that want franking credits. There's going to be a lot less access to this. And, you know, to step into volatile equity markets is not necessarily what everyone's after, to be able to receive it via dividends. Um, and the other big loser for us, we actually think tier two bonds actually will trade water off the back of this and probably will trend wider for the next sort of year.

5:14

Um so those are kind of I would round out our big three losers. And on the flip side, Charlie, you saying the insurers. You mentioned that. Why? Why are they potential winners here then? Yeah. Uh, simple answer is supply. Demand. Um, uh, everyone likes to hide behind that veil, but insurance is the biggest winner. And the reason why is because there's been no proposed changes to their capital requirements and the way that they can issue regulatory capital securities. And, um, if you talk about insurers having to issue at a rate over and above three month BW on the AT1 hybrids, we think that that rate has a potential to come in circa 50, 75 basis points from where it is today. When you're talking about a market that's going to shrink from being over $40 billion in size to being, you know, circa $3 billion in size with only seven securities on it. So those those those insurance issuers of AT1 hybrids, they're going to have to pay a lot less

6:14

for their AT1 capital. And so that's a massive win for them Uh, the second winners would be the listed bond market. So there's not many listed bonds in Australia anymore, and there's not really any corporate hybrids. There used to be a really robust corporate hybrid market, uh, in Australia in the early 2000. We think that this could potentially mark the return for for some of those issuers, because if you're a savvy corporate treasurer, you'll recognize that the rates that you're going to be able to issue into the ASX market are going to be materially lower, materially lower than what you would otherwise be issuing into the wholesale OTC market. So we think that this, you know, it's not great from an investor perspective, but the silver lining might be access to a broader base, a broader base of diversified income via corporate hybrids and listed bonds. And then the other the other one is the income limits. So if you think about listed investment trusts, there hasn't been a lot of

7:14

new issuance IPOs since the removal of stamping fees. But we expect that a lot of investors will be forced into some of the private debt products or some of the income products. Um, so names like MGT Mott Sri at ET al. Um, but also, you know, it gives the space for new issuers and products to emerge to fill this gap.

7:34

And Kelly, is this a given? Um, is it, um, now expected to be put in place, and if so, when?

7:44

Yeah. Great question Andrew. So it is still proposed. Uh, just to be clear, but when these kinds of proposals come through, um, there will be, you know, robust consultation with the industry, but generally the changes kind of only tinker at the margins, particularly with bank capital framework type, uh, proposals. So we think the Rubicon has been crossed here. There might be some very minor tweaks, but we think it's highly likely that from January 2027, these new requirements will be effective and the official transition will have started. Um, you know, we think that there is you know, it's unclear as to whether more AT1 hybrids can be issued between now and 2027. Um, but we think from that date that there will there will be no more, uh, without question.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy