A wake up call for fund managers
About this video
Key points
Data shows most Australian active equity funds underperform the S&P/ASX 200
Professionalisation, costs and return skew as key headwinds for active managers
Stock dispersion has risen but say active managers still struggle to outperform
ETF and index investing is expected to grow, especially among younger Australian investors
A new S&P Dow Jones Indices scorecard is cited by Sue Lee as showing a majority of Australian active equity funds lagging their benchmarks in 2025, reinforcing the structural challenge for stock pickers. Lee says around 74% of Australian general equity funds underperform the S&P/ASX 200, with mid-to-small cap managers doing slightly better and active A-REIT and bond funds faring relatively well. Despite higher stock dispersion and sector rotation, which Lee views as a favourable backdrop for stock selection, most active managers are described as failing to translate this into benchmark-beating returns over time.
Duncan Burns from Vanguard Australia points to long-term data suggesting roughly 80% of active managers trail their index after fees. Burns attributes this to increasingly professionalised markets, higher active costs and skewed return distributions where a small group of “mega winners” drives overall performance. He argues investors do not need to beat the market to have a strong experience, framing low-cost index funds and ETFs as compelling options.
Both Lee and Burns expect passive and ETF investing to keep expanding in Australia, particularly among younger investors using ETFs for broad market and index-based strategies. Burns rejects claims that index funds distort markets, highlighting that active managers still dominate trading and price discovery.